BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Greenpeace & activism...where do you draw the line?

 
 
Grey Area
21:49 / 20.06.04


Reading this article, the thought occured to me that this could technically be described as piracy. I mean, they've boarded a ship and taken over the running of it, even though the captain 'is still in control'.

Greenpeace have always managed to grab headlines with their activities in the past, and I do take my hat off to the people who go out and do this, but this action is venturing into a grey area. When does the moral justification for activism no longer outweigh the fact that you're breaking the law?

Point: The crew of this vessel are, for want of a better term, prisoners of Greenpeace. The activists are preventing them from reaching shore by refusing to let the pilot on board.

Point: The vessel needs to be refueled before it can return to the US. How is Greenpeace suggesting this be achieved without the vessel berthing at a harbour? Are they going to front the cost of having a tender vessel sail out and resupply the cargo ship?

So where does one draw the line? Is there in fact a line? At what point do actions like this to more to damage the cause than further it?
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
10:08 / 21.06.04
And let's hope they've got their facts right this time...
 
 
Whale... Whale... Fish!
00:40 / 23.06.04
...but do you want to take the risk "that milk from animals fed on GM crops does not contain any GM material"?
 
 
Jester
07:51 / 26.06.04
Well, I don't know that they're doing anything that terrible. If it was a case of refueling and taking the GM stuff back to the U S of A, I'm sure that Greenpeace would have absolutely no problem facilitating that.

If the law is not protecting you (like our laws are not protecting our food chain from GMOs) then yeah, I think there is a total justification. Look. The anti-apartheid movement broke laws. So have lots of peace/protest movements. The law is not the be all or end all.
 
 
Tryphena Absent
20:13 / 26.06.04
The line has to be drawn with the question- are they endangering anyone? Protests always inconvenience someone, they're meant to, it's when a crowd doesn't move for an ambulance that there's a problem. The same basic logic should surely be applied here?
 
 
flufeemunk effluvia
00:20 / 28.06.04
YAR! THIS VESSEL SHALL BE COMMANDEERED... BY ME HIPPIE CREW!

HAR HAR HAR!
 
  
Add Your Reply