BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Stepford Second Wives

 
 
cusm
19:47 / 17.06.04
Anyone catch the Stepford Wives remake recently? If not, let me save you some trouble. Its comedy. Really, more a mockery of the original that a remake. Amusing and entertaining, I'll give it, but not quality cinema by any stretch.

It was cause for me to watch the original again, and the differences in overall style of moviemaking between the two were really noticable for me, in a way that spoke much of current Hollywood in general.

The original was subtle. It didn't insult your intelligence. Details were illuded to, not spoon fed to you in monologing explainations. You never once are told what is happening, you see the character figure it out and know from that. A fine example is the first night the husband comes home from the Men's Association, and stays downstairs drinking. He's clearly upset. He tells his wife that he loves her, emotionally. And you know from just that much that maybe he does, but he's already made the decison for murder and there's no going back. Even towards the end, your only explaination to How is the workplaces she drives by and her clearly wondering what could go on there. Good stuff, left to the viewer to piece together.

And it was creepy. There's a slow unraveling of characters. You're left with enough reason to believe that it might all still be madness, and when its too late to discount, its horifficly so.

In the remake, its blatently obvious the whole time and the point of jokes. There's a stupid CGI robot dog that was completely unnecessary.

The social commentary is mocked as well, but maybe that much I can understand. The original was powerful at the time because of the state of social movements. Today, there is enough equality that this can be a joke. Even the demasculination of the men of Stepford as whiny geeks was a pointed reversal of the power issues in the original. In a way, it was more an un-make than a re-make, in how much was reversed.

But I'll bet Bette Milder was jumping for her part. She was such the right choice for Bobby, and must have had a blast with it.
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
13:33 / 18.06.04
I dunno - isn't it pretty much impossible to do a remake of the Stepford Wives with the same suspense, because everyone already knows the twist?

As for the whiny geeks - well, isn't the point that these man are wealthy but unpleasant, and that they see replacing their wives with robots not as a heart-wrenching act of sin, but like getting a Bose stereo? Hence all the luxury brands being referenced?
 
 
delta venus
00:42 / 20.06.04
more an un-make than a re-make

...aaand that's how cusm made me go see The Stepford Wives.
 
 
FinderWolf
14:04 / 23.06.04
I heard this is not so hot -- what did those of you who saw it think?
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
11:24 / 14.01.06
Must... resist... urge... to batter myself into... unconsciousness. I've got the DVD playing now and, as far as I can tell, the only thing in it's favour is that it's 90 minutes long so nice and short.

Is it worth seeking out the original?
 
 
modern maenad
11:42 / 14.01.06
Our Lady - Abso-fucking-lutely. In the 70's film makers were actually allowed to make films that challenged the viewer. Films with fibre, one might even say. And from a feminist point of view watching movies such as the original Stepford Wives is simultaneously refreshing and excruciating, as they hold up a very big, revalatory mirror to the utterly pappy safe stereotypical blandness masquarading as 'feminist' aka 'grrll power' in film at the moment.
 
 
matthew.
12:59 / 14.01.06
I thought the remake was enjoyable. Nothing too deep or difficult about it. Simply a moderately dark comedy. The only good part is Roger Bart and Bette Midler. Nicole Kidman just seems so robotic, pardon the pun, as an actress. I have yet to see her in a movie where she blows me away.
 
 
grant
14:05 / 17.01.06
The original is outstanding. The remake is... well, Frank Oz. Has a muppet flavor.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
14:27 / 17.01.06
I'm not sure that as a general rule I'd go along with the idea that "In the 70's film makers were actually allowed to make films that challenged the viewer. Films with fibre etc etc" - smacks of rose-tinted glasses to me.
 
 
modern maenad
15:24 / 17.01.06
ORIGINAL STEPFORD WIVES SPOILERS

Petey - I'm mainly refering to the fact that a higher proportion of 70's films have unanticipated/tragic endings, such as the death of the main character in the origninal Stepford Wives. Notwithstanding independent film, big studio releases almost unanimously take the feel good easy option nowadays. Having said all that I'm no movie buff and am happy to stand corrected on this one.
 
  
Add Your Reply