BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Carandiru

 
 
D Terminator XXXIII
11:10 / 08.06.04
Carandiru - the acclaimed new movie by Hector Babenco (he of the Two Imprisoned Men Who Kiss Each Other While the Spider Gazes with William Hurt and Raoul, ah, Addams) goes criminally underreported by the Latin American Barbelith members?

Has won numerous awards.

And, essentially, good.

Looking at the first many pages of the Film, TV and Theater section, one can only marvel at the predominance of Western mainstream junk. Let's slightly alter this fact, what?

'Cos the movie's really good <- pressed for time. Really, really good. <- still pressed for time.
 
 
D Terminator XXXIII
08:17 / 10.06.04
And less pressed for time today, hence ...

... why you should see this movie:

- This movie’s good.

- Really, really good.

- No, really.

Yes. Really.

Rare is the film in today’s climate which doesn’t take the easier available routes to target the lowest common denominators. Carandiru is one such film.

The perversion of the movie is ingenious, and yet so simple. A humanization of the crooks, the criminals, murderers, robbers, and drug dealers & users. No simplistic good and bad dichotomy is employed within the movie – that is, not until much later – when accounting for, and recounting the reasons why these people have been transplanted to the confined space that was Carandiru; and real confined it was too: built for 3500, used by up to 7000 in 1992…

Babenco and the other filmmakers have finalized the proceedings so that in the 2½ hours duration, the impression of a sensitive, poetic pace, which unfailingly showers everyone involved with affection is the dominant theme, despite the eventual horrendous fate of 111 prisoners.

(& again, I wonder why the Brazilian members haven't reported this to us, in the first place)
 
 
H3ct0r L1m4
02:23 / 01.07.04
hm, I haven't been to the forum in quite a while - and I wasn't aware it was being shown in the north hemisphere already. CARANDIRU is just an OK movie not only for Babenco [a director that somehow has lost it - check KISS OF THE SPIDER WOMAN, PIXOTE, IRONWEED and PLAYING AT THE FIELDS OF THE LORD to know what I'm talking about], but also for the strengh of the theme, one that has had so much impact in ou culture as of late. but it turned out to be our strongest box office, even more than CITY OF GOD [a better movie] was.

it was based on a book, CARANDIRU STATION [no Englsh edition yet, as far as I'm concerned], in which the doctor reccounts the many stories he heard from the inmates gathered when he worked there.

I've heard the documentary THE IRON CAGE PRISONER is a much stronger piece. still haven't seen it. CARANDIRU the movie has its moments, but it's just... banal in the end.
 
  
Add Your Reply