BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Superman: Secret Identity

 
 
Tamayyurt
23:32 / 13.05.04
Has anybody else been getting this? I just read the last issue of the mini and I have to say that it is the best Superman tale I've ever read. It's just so realistic and personal and sweet. It's what I think of as what a Superman movie should be. And Start Immonen's art is perfect, it's like photos instead of drawings and the effect is awe inspiring and grounding at the same time.

If you haven’t picked this up I highly recommend it.

And if you have… thoughts?
 
 
fluid_state
13:42 / 14.05.04
Loved it. I thought it was a one shot, and was pleasantly surprised to find "to be continued" at the end of the first book. The first book could stand on it's own, though. It may all seem a little contrived (Clark Kent?!? come on. Only a very bitter parent would name... anyway), but it is a fantastic look at the evolution of a "real-world" Superman. Whereas in Astro City, you get glimpses and facets of characters over time, this is the start-to-finish look at just one. Great stuff.
 
 
FinderWolf
14:00 / 14.05.04
This book was terrific and wonderful, art and story-wise. I read it from the beginning. Really first class work from Busiek & the immensely talented Immonen, who takes new steps in his evolution as an artist here. Glad you started a thread on this, Imp!
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
14:05 / 14.05.04
Echo.

Totally fantastic book from front to back. And Immomen really turned up the heat. I read an interview where he described the process, as he colored the entire thing himself as well.

I think my favorite aspect was how Clark's powers gave him the insight he used to write his books. Nice touch.
 
 
Tamayyurt
19:07 / 14.05.04
oh good, I thought nobody had read it (or worse, didn't like it enough to comment). Glad people are enjoying this.

I like how after reading the first issue I thought it was going to be my favorite. Then I read the Lois one and thought, man, this can't get any better. Until he became a father and again I thought wow, this one is the best issue AND THEN he got old and it was so great! I still can't decide which one I like best.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
19:34 / 14.05.04
Yeah, its structure is so fantastic that way. It's very rare, actually, in comics these days. Clearly a unified storyline that carries through all four issues, but made up of four completely unique segments. As opposed to the 96 page story split up into three issues, this was clearly four stories making up one story. Done very effectively, especially in the design aspect, as far as the covers went. That simple background image of his daughters flying in tandem was so sweet and so indicative of the book's contents, well, just such a great job.

I also liked how casually and realistically it handled Clark's interracial relationship with Lois. Probably one of the most realistic relationships ever illustrated under the DC logo.

So much to love about this book. They ought to release it as a hardcover and give it the same critical press that they did for "It's A Bird". Superman is so iconagraphic a character, that this piece would clearly resonate with a larger audience. Maybe even more so than Seagle's. It's almost a Contemporary Literature Superman (Joyce Carol Oates, Alice Sebold) as opposed to a Postmodern Literature Superman.

And yet, obviously, it works so well as a comic book, narratively and visually. Those double and single page splashes, I'd go so far as to say every single one of them, were just breathtaking. Such a great balance between the prose of the story of the visuals.

Yeah, great book. And very deserving of wider recognition once its collected.
 
  
Add Your Reply