BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


David Mitchell

 
 
Jester
14:16 / 19.04.04
Has anyone else been reading Cloud Atlas? I'm right in the middle of it, and loving it. I'm especially loving the crazy future language, even if it is a bit Mad Max.

The way it is cutting between different narrative threads reminds me of Italo Calvino If on a winter's night a traveller..., but with less of the self consciously post modernity. It's also much more sucessful, in that I am actually tantalised by the snippets of story. Thoughts?

Anyone read any of his other books? Can you recommend them?
 
 
Squirmelia
20:52 / 19.04.04
I recently read Ghostwritten. I found it a bit confusing - maybe because I didn't realize it was supposed to be 9 interlinked separate stories. It was interesting at times, fairly good, but not amazing.
 
 
The Strobe
09:46 / 20.04.04
I tried a thread about number9dream a while back. It started well, but devolved into sub-Murakami, and as such, was incredibly disappointing. Very good in parts, but not overall. Shame. More on it in that thread (which is yikes, over two years old).
 
 
rizla mission
10:28 / 20.04.04
I've read Ghostwritten.

Generally it was excellent. Very ambitious, and generally it managed to maintain a sufficient level of quality to fulfill it's ambition. There were occasional sections I thought were absolutely cringeworthy (the chapters set in London and Ireland), and most of the attempts at humour were pretty dreadful, but the many good bits more than made up for that.

It suceeded where many others have failed, in that it was a modern-literary-fiction-magical-realism-Guardian-reading-trendy-bollocks-modern-novel book that I actually found really interesting, engaging and enjoyable. The little bits of sci-fi creeping in around the edges were a particular treat.

Oddly, it's possibly the first book in history that my brother, my mother and myself have all read and all enjoyed.

I hear his new book is in part a John Wyndham style disaster thingy, so naturally I'd be interested in checking that out..
 
 
Jester
10:52 / 20.04.04
Rizla and the Ultraviolet: Yep, there is something John Wyndum/sci-fi about Cloud Atlas. It actually works incredibly well: especially the parts that are set in a future China. There are some really clever moments, and he does some sophisticated things that transcend the sci-fi genre. Partly this is the time skippage: the book starts in the 1700s moving through into an apocalyptic future. Like I said, I really like the way he renders the language of the future. I really want to give examples, but that would take away from the pleasure of anyone wanting to actually read it I've been finding that each time shift starts out feeling a little bit awkward, but it evens out as it goes along.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
15:29 / 09.11.04
I've just read Number 9 Dream, which I adored, and have just been lent Ghostwritten by one of my work minions.

N9D... yes, I did adore it, but some of it seemed- not thrown together, maybe the opposite... he seemed a little eager to get EVERYTHING in there. 99% of the time it worked... and there was something endearing about the whole thing. Not just about Eiji- the book itself was very likeable, so I was prepared to forgive it the bits where I thought it didn't quite work.

I'm looking forward to Ghostwritten... and then, I guess, Cloud Atlas'll be on my list when next I get paid.
 
 
misterpc
20:07 / 12.11.04
I read the books in the order they were written, and it helped me to see where he is going as a writer. It's interesting to watch a writer growing, getting better control of his themes, developing a more fluid style. And one thing you can't accuse him of is a lack of ambition.

In the end, though, the reason that I've found his books enjoyable - even where they're patchy - is because he writes interesting stories. Cloud Atlas illustrates this nicely: I didn't keep reading because I was fascinated by the structural device he was using but because I wanted to know what was going to happen next. Frankly, there are very few mainstream, 'literary' writers (and believe me, I hate using that term) that can do that.

I'm thinking of going to see Mitchell talk at the Criterion theatre next week. Anybody up for going?
 
  
Add Your Reply