BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Sedna: 10th planet?

 
 
The resistable rise of Reidcourchie
11:21 / 15.03.04
Sedna is the Inuit god of the sea/underworld. So not only have we rocked the astronomers the greco/roman monopoly on planet names but is it a planet at all or a big rock?

Anyone know why it was named Sedna?

What with earth apparently having two moons space is getting crowded.
 
 
hanabius yamamura
12:50 / 15.03.04
... can't help but be drawn to the fact that it's ANDES spelt backwards (no disrespect intended to any Inuits reading) ... what name will they use next? SMROGNRIAC?
 
 
sleazenation
14:08 / 15.03.04
It would also seem to play into the hands of the significant lobby that this is not another planet but one of the larger Kuiper belt object. Hell, there is even a significant case againt Pluto being termed a planet...

 
 
Mister Six, whom all the girls
00:18 / 16.03.04
Silly humans... Mondas is the 10th Planet and the Cybermen will destroy you!
 
 
The resistable rise of Reidcourchie
07:24 / 16.03.04
Yep, that's what I figured.
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
11:44 / 16.03.04
Shouldn't it be the ninth planet? I was reading something somewhere about how astronmers said that if they discovered Pluto today they wouldn't consider it a planet and it was only because so little was known about it when it was discovered that it got away with being designated a planet. Damn, where did I read that?
 
 
Tryphena Absent
13:04 / 16.03.04
Are you sure you haven't just been watching The West Wing Flowers?
 
 
distractile
15:36 / 16.03.04
Yeah, Pluto is pretty poor excuse for a planet: it's too small and its orbit is too weird. But Sedna is smaller and more eccentric still, so if you count out Pluto, you have to count out Sedna too (and all the other remote planetoids discovered over the past few years).
 
 
archon666
22:18 / 16.03.04


..but aren't all s0-called 'planets' nothing more than arbitray concepts that are only mere reference points to place some type of s0-called 'meaning' to how space 'should' operate....

along the lines that there can never be any object that travels faster than the speed of light as laid down by uncle al to the point of becoming a fault in and of itself...

how fascinating i am that human conceptions are considered 'laws' of un-shakeable magnitude until the g0ddess herself smiles: laughs: and farts to scare the hell out of them.....
 
 
Jub
10:55 / 24.03.04
Okay - I just posted this in Q&A in conversation but then I found this thread! So I'll ask again.... I want to know why Mr-I'm-going-to-name-this-planet-before-anyone-else-has-a-say-so, decided to name the planet Sedna - seriously. Fair play to the Goddess herself, I'm sure she was very good at being powerful and sea-like and everything but won't she feel a bit left out with the Greek and Romans up there. I mean - for the sake of uniformity if nothing else, why not Greek or Roman and WHY Inuit for fuck's sake? Is there any good reason other than the word Sedna sounding kinda cool? Anyone?
 
 
invisible_al
12:43 / 24.03.04
*Ahem* from http://www.gps.caltech.edu/~mbrown/sedna/

" 2003 VB12 is the official temporary designation of the International Astronomical Union (IAU) Minor Planet Center, based on the year (2003) and date (14 Nov = the 22nd 2-week period of the year thus V=the 22nd letter of the alphabet. after that it is sequential based on the discovery announcement) of discovery. Once the orbit of 2003 VB12 is known well enough (probably 1 year), we will reccomend to the IAU Committee on Small Body Nomenclature -- which is responsible for solar system names -- that it be permanently called Sedna. Our newly discovered object is the coldest most distant place known in the solar system, so we feel it is appropriate to name it in honor of Sedna, the Inuit goddess of the sea, who is thought to live at the bottom of the frigid arctic ocean. We will furthermore suggest to the IAU that newly discoverd objects in this inner Oort cloud all be named after entities in arctic mythologies."

Also if they're going to name all the objects of this size in the Oort cloud they're going to run out of names from just one patheon pretty quickly. Also why not because it sounds cool?

Update - from http://www.gps.caltech.edu/~chad/2004dw/ about another object found by the same team.

"After the object is numbered, then the discoverers (that's us) have one decade to propose a name to the Internation Astronomical Union. There are even more rules about the name of the object. 2004 DW, for instance, must be named after an underworld deity because it is in a Pluto-like orbit."
 
 
Jub
13:25 / 24.03.04
Also if they're going to name all the objects of this size in the Oort cloud they're going to run out of names from just one patheon pretty quickly. Also why not because it sounds cool?

Haven't got a problem with it sounding cool... in fact that's the only thing it has going for it. The Greco-Roman Pantheon rocks is all, you'd have trouble running out of dieties - whereas I guess the Inuit one is pretty small.

Why Inuit?! This is what I want to know. They could have had loads of others eg Poliahu who was the Polynesian Snow Goddess.
 
 
Neosata, master of space
01:53 / 15.04.04
I don't understand... is it a flippin' planet or not?!?!? Has NASA even decided? I need answers!!!!!!!!!!!!! ... (please)
 
 
Cloned Christ on a HoverDonkey
01:35 / 16.04.04
The latest Sedna news...

Basically, I think all this story says (apart from the fact that they were wrong to begin with) is that they need to make the definition of what constitutes a planet more strict.

Interesting, nonetheless.
 
 
matsya
02:15 / 20.04.04
Well, there's also Quaoar, which is named after the creation force of the Tongva tribe of the Los Angeles basin, and Varuna, which is named after the Vedic god of the cosmos, the keeper of divine order, the bringer of rain and the enforcer of contracts, so they're mixin' it up a bit these days.

m.
 
 
sleazenation
21:05 / 24.08.06
Remember that 'significant case against Pluto' being a planet that I mentioned up thread? Looks like the majority of astronomers agree - Pluto is no longer a planet... details here...
 
 
Dead Megatron
22:04 / 24.08.06
And whatever happened to Sedna, btw? Nobody is mentioning Sedna in all this "who's a planet?" mess.
 
 
invisible_al
10:49 / 14.09.06
2003 UB313 aka 'Xena' has just got itself a proper name Eris, she also has a moon as well Dysnomia named after the Goddess of Lawlessness.

Apparently after all the trouble she's caused the choice of name was "too perfect to resist" .
 
 
Quantum
16:36 / 14.09.06
Fnording fantastic!
 
 
grant
17:02 / 14.09.06
Awwww. Like the dawning of a new age.
 
 
Red Concrete
20:40 / 14.09.06
Hot Dog! Much nicer than "Xena"...
 
 
Saint Keggers
23:44 / 14.09.06
But I was hoping Xena would give us a moon named Joxer.

I woke up, heard the news. My inner Discordian smiled. (My outer Discordian was distracted by something shiny.)
 
  
Add Your Reply