|
|
I was fully prepared to start making Naked City comparisons when I first heard this new album--Book 1 compared with Torture Garden, Director's Cut compared with Radio, and Delirium Cordia compared with Leng Tchi....
Upon listening to this album further I decided the comparison just doesn't hold up. DC seems more in line with Zorn's Filmworks projects, especially Volume 2 (music for an untitled film by Walter Hill). The difference between them betrays Patton's genius: the Zorn album was made to go with a film, while the new Fantomas album needs no accompaniment (unless you count the darkened room and the bong). It communicates feelings (dread, giddiness, anger, lighthearted laughter) purely through sound. Absinthe doesn't communicate much of anything to me, and seems to serve best as "framing" for the other Naked City projects (I have all of my NC tracks on my X-Box so I can listen to it all in random order--it seems to work so much better this way than album by album).
To be fair, I've enjoyed each Fantomas album for very different reasons as each has been released, and my tastes obviously don't jive with the mainstream...and I've been a fan of Naked City for years as well...so...oh, I don't know.
I am very much looking forward to the other album from Fantomas later this year, which I've heard will have more of a Carl Stalling/cartoon feel. This doesn't really make much of an arguement against the Patton-ripping-off-Zorn argument, but I'm excited none-the-less. |
|
|