BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Your Favorite Comic Endings?

 
  

Page: (1)2

 
 
Tamayyurt
14:58 / 19.12.03
This has pretty much come from someone's comments over in the NXM #150 about Grant rushing endings and a comversation with a friend of mine about the end of Promethea and Moore not writing good endings as well (which I don't really get as Watchmen had an awesome ending but...)

So what are your favorite endings in comic books? What did you especially like about it. And give a little rundown incase it's something all of us hasn't read.
 
 
delta venus
15:45 / 19.12.03
Like most of Milligan's work, it's a bit dated upon review, but I dearly love the ending of ENIGMA. As a study in Existentialism, the story ends perfectly (with a gimmicky but fitting circular storytelling gambit on the last page). There are three parts to the last scene, for those who didn't read it or have gotten fuzzy.

1) Michael learns that his (possibly latent, possibly heretofore nonexistent) homosexuality was imposed on him by his lover, the Enigma, in order to effectively reprogram (through psychic feedback) the Enigma's Death Mother-slash-shadow anima. Given the opportunity to change back, Michael gives the post-existentialist "fuck it" reply along the lines of "nobody knows why I have green eyes either, but I like them."

2) The entire story's narrator is revealed to be a similarly altered lizard incapable of communicating with anyone but his fellow idiotic lizards, in parallel with the Enigma's Omega-Level mutation (in the TPB intro Grant calls this reveal a further parallel to the abomination that caused the Enigma's initial retreat into existentialist recreation of a 60's comic book, in that it effectively pulls the entire structure of the Enigma narrative apart -- it becomes a tale told to no one, by no one). There is a circular gimmick to this narrative that makes it kind of cheap, however, it leads directly into the best part of the conclusion.

3) Having been shown the real nature of the story we've been reading, it now makes sense that we should stay with the lizard narrator and miss the real climax/conclusion of the story -- the Enigma, Michael, and *another* comic book writer stand-in head off down the hill to confront the death mother figure and see if the entire experiment with the mutations has worked. In one step we've lost the opportunity to view the conclusion to the original story, and come into a much bigger story, this one about the act of comics and storytelling in general ... and this reframing is retroactive, making the whole story about the telling of that story leading to that one unending moment of conclusion that we're unable to resolve even using our own powers of existentialist re-creation. It's very nice.

For extra credit I'll also say that this "reframing from within" technique was used to Awesome effect in post-Kathy SHADE, when we find out (SPOILER WARNINGS are redundant in this thread, eh?) that Shade's power is pretty much *directly responsible* for everything that's gone before, making it a metaphor for the power of our unconscious desires and resentments to fuck up everything and create the world around us moment by moment. Similarly religious to the bits above, in that I was in high school and could neither spell existentialism nor define passive-aggressive. I will always love you, Peter.
 
 
Mr Tricks
15:53 / 19.12.03
Another Milligan Ending of note was in Rogan Gosh where the lead charactor returns from his state of enlightenment to make amends to his Girlfriend. As he makes his way through the growning mundaness of London his enlighenment continues to fade away until it is only a lotus blossum in his hand by the time he knocks on his ex-girlfriend's front door. Though he's forgotten all of his insights the presentation of this flower is enough to earn forgivenss from her...


sounds silly but worked wonders when read.
 
 
gergsnickle
16:24 / 19.12.03
The death of Gwen Stacy followed by the death of the original Green Goblin in Amazing Spider-Man (like #s 121-122 or around there).

Recap: Norman Osborne, the original Green Goblin takes Gwen Stacy high atop the GWB and then, whilst battling the meddling wall-crawler, KNOCKS HER OFF (both the bridge, and, in the process, euphemistically as well). Apparently she died from shock (or did she break her neck?). Then, next issue, the Goblin is impaled on his own bat-glider while grappling with Spidey.

Now THAT'S an ending - back when major characters didn't die for good - just in case you thought Peter Parker's personal life might work out all right, think again.

Oh, and of course the 3rd volume of the Invisibles
 
 
pachinko droog
16:55 / 19.12.03
Really enjoyed the ending to JLA:WWIII (it also being the ending of Grant's run on the series).

*Spolier-ish:*

Everyone on earth becoming a superhero and rising to the challenge...I thought it meshed nicely with what he was doing with The Invisibles, as well as his theories on evolution/novelty and sunspot cycles and all that.

His JLA work has A LOT of subtext to it, even though many like to portray/downgrade it as "kids' stuff".
 
 
PatrickMM
17:35 / 19.12.03
I never got the idea that Grant ends his series poorly, since for me, Invisibles 3.1 is probably the best issue of the run. And the rest of volume III is completely illuminating. So The Invisibles would probably be my favorite end.

Then there's Animal Man, which the last 8 issues or so are simply phenomenal. From the peyote trip to issue 26, it's all great stuff.

Watchmen's ending is genius and really makes you think. Plus, that last panel is killer.

If you count The Kindly Ones as the real end of Sandman, it's got a phenomenal close. However, the last six issues seem sort of redundant.
 
 
quinine92001
00:31 / 20.12.03
Earth X: Recap-Superheroes are antibodies that are unknowingly defeating anything on Earth in order to protect the unborn Celestial embryo growing within the Earth. Vibranium. Everything is Vibranium.
Franklin Richards returns to Earth outfitted in Galatacus' sink suit to fight the Celestials, after a Howard Hughes Tony Stark tries and fails to defeat them in his final Iron Man suit made up of part of a city.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
02:33 / 20.12.03
I remember reading Killing Joke when I was a kid and loving that ending. Still love it now.
 
 
Krug
05:06 / 20.12.03
SPOILERS! (What else?)

Ghost World: When I was reading it for the first time, the first three chapters were very funny verging on bleak and sad. I was definitely laughing too hard because it seemed like Clowes turned everything on it's head and changed the music completely in the last chapter and everything connected on a personal note. On a second reading it seems that everytime the words "Ghost World" appear or are said, Clowes is casting a spell with the very words. And it does truly become "Ghost World" in the end. It's definitely the most heartbreaking ending in comics.

Miracleman Olympus: It begins to reek of a sad finality in the early pages and with the monolog about how Olympus has haunted the dreams of man and all we have to do is look up at the stars it seems that Moore can't top himself at the end but that last page is unforgettable.

St. Swithin's Day: It's a very depressing story that just keeps on sinking with the reader's heart but Grant managed to end it happily without spoiling the preceding content.

Best Man Fall: It's the highest point of the Invisibles, the most promising moment which, in all it's promise tells us how magnificent and chaotic the whole thing is. No other single comic has a wealth of singly devastating and affecting panels and Grant ends it not at the ending but where the reader wants it to end.

David Boring: I was a bit dismayed by the final panges because after the whole scene in the theatre ("Such narrative symmetry cannot bode well, this must be the end"), David's just so beaten by everything, telephoning Dot for the last time, at the bridge with the cops...the book reached it's zenith. It was topnotch stuff and David should've just jumped. Clowes built everything up to that point and it seemed as if a great tragedy lurked behind the curtain of the ending. Everything had come together so marvelously until Dot saved him. I thought it was a sympathy/pity ending similar to how Nabokov ends Bend Sinister though lacking in it's oversubtley and execution.

Animal Man: I was all choked up by Grant's talk with buddy and the Foxy scene made me want to bawl.

Transmetropolitan "Another Cold Morning": The Best story Warren Ellis has written and possibly may ever write. The page with Spider just staring out in the snow flicking his cigarette away. Goes out with respect.

Goldfish: One hardly expects Bendis to make a soapbox out of a noir. The second ending does not tamper with the tragedy of the first one and still manages to go out explosively.
 
 
raelianautopsy
05:08 / 20.12.03
Earth X had a great ending but that last Paradise X sure didn't.

Sandman had a great ending. The best way to feel closure in a story is to have an intense climax and ending and then an epilogue. The Kindly Ones had the best climax and then the Wake had a good epilogue that gives you an idea of what happened to the other characters with a bittersweet epilogue.

Grant Morrison is the type of hyper-intellectual writer that is good at the middle of the story and the majority of his work is made up of that, but fair at the beginning part, and not good at the ending.

With super-hero comics some of the best endings are cosmic storylines. Lot's of Claremont X-Mens like the Dark Phoenix saga, the original Brood saga, the Fall of the Mutants. Crossovers can be annoying but usually the central storyline is good: Secret Wars and the Infinity Gauntlet had good endings. I think Joe Kelley is good with that, his endings for Superman crossovers like the Braniac 13/Metropolis storyline, the Joker takes over the world one, and the War of the Worlds were good.

For cosmic epicness, End of Evengalion is as good as it gets. Although that's not a comic, close enough.
 
 
Scrambled Password Bogus Email
10:28 / 20.12.03
Blood : A Tale.

Fucking awesome.
 
 
Troy Wilson
18:01 / 20.12.03
I enthusiastically second Enigma, Miracleman:Olympus, Animal Man, the Best Man Fall issue, Sandman, Dark Phoenix, and the original Brood saga. Watchmen too, despite its biggest flaw (namely, why would the smartest man on the earth believe peaceful unity would last after, say, two years with no actual aliens?).

I'd throw in Moore's Swamp Thing ending and Morrison's Doom Patrol ending. Two happily-ever-after conclusions that didn't make me lose my lunch.

Anyone read Peter David's last issue of the Hulk? I've heard good things, but haven't read it myself.
 
 
Bed Head
18:38 / 20.12.03
God yes, The Empire of Chairs! Anybody who ever again dares say that Morrison doesn’t know how to end a comic, should have a rolled-up copy of this stuffed down their stupid throat. For starters.
Granted, he normally tends to fluff it, but this once managed to write the sweetest, most affecting, most beautiful comic *ever*. That’s enough for any lifetime. I dearly love his other stuff, but this was perfect.

The much-praised Watchman ending? Don’t get it. Haven’t ever got it. Don’t understand at all how a devastating attack on New York is supposed to defuse an arms race. It looks even more stupid these days. Although, to prove I’m not just yanking Moore’s beard for the sake of it I’ll say I like the ending to V For Vendetta: sad, chaotic, hopeful, uncertain. Just the right tone.
 
 
PatrickMM
14:27 / 22.12.03
The much-praised Watchman ending? Don’t get it. Haven’t ever got it. Don’t understand at all how a devastating attack on New York is supposed to defuse an arms race. It looks even more stupid these days.

Look at post 9/11. For a good year or so, basically every country in the world was ready to back up the US in whatever they needed to do to capture bin Laden. Tony Blair's Britain is still backing us up with whatever is "needed." And I think the brief global coming together, which gradually falls apart, post 9/11, is perfectly captured in Watchmen.

As for why Veidt thinks the alien attack would work, I think in their world, they're at the point where any day an attack could happen, so if he could buy one or two years, that would give everyone a chance to cool down and reassess what's going on. I don't think the aliens were ever the permanent solution, they were just a way to get people to the table. Veidt may have gotten a bit too caught up in the initial reports of peace, and that's why he's so happy at the end of the book. And, Manhattan does challenge him at the end.
 
 
Keith
16:08 / 22.12.03
Moonshadow. Nuff Said...
 
 
Elijah, Freelance Rabbi
18:23 / 28.12.03
i gotta say animal man has to be my favorite end of a run ever. i really was crying when i was reading it.
 
 
■
19:07 / 28.12.03
Don't forget the end of Watchmen was in fact the sting that Rorschach's diary was probably about to be published.
 
 
■
19:09 / 28.12.03
Oooh, oooh. Small Killing! Small Killing! (and Signal to Noise... why did Gollancz back such wonders while also plugging turkeys like Ian Miller...)
 
 
01
04:06 / 30.12.03
Jeez, I never thought of that after having been a huge Watchmen. That Rorsach's journal probably would've been published. I always thought that last panel left the story completely open, if anything leaning to the side that the journal wouldn't be published. Damn brilliant book. Almost 20 years later and still kicking my ass.
 
 
Ben Danes
08:03 / 30.12.03
Animal Man is one of the best, though I'm really fond of the Invisibles and how Dane has a chat to all of us, that I'd say it's the best.

Earth X was really good in the end. I liked how the end of each issue kept on increasing the stakes: inside the Earth is a growing Celestial; we're antibodies; Galactus! etc. Shame the follow ups weren't as good (although I still like that Cap special, which was/would be the perfect end story for the character.)

The last No Man's Land story by Rucka, 'Days of Auld Lang Syne' was a good ending as well. It was dark, but at the same time it seemed really uplifting, especially at the end. I still remember that last page:Batman at his parent's grave, with the POV of the reader looking up at him, with fireworks going off in the sky. And Gordon singing Days of Auld Lang Syne at his wife's grave gets ya.
 
 
Isalie
07:45 / 01.01.04
I read Paul Popes "Heavy Liquid" recently, and that was a twist that just keeps growing on me.

"Hello mister radiowave spaceman."

And yes, Animal man was fantastic at the end.
 
 
NezZ the 2nd
12:18 / 01.01.04
Akira, the whole of volume 6 (recent darkhorse tpb), that whole chapter is amazing and so full of emotion.

Watchmen, nuff said.

Preacher, i liked the ending, it wrapped it all up nicely.

Uzumaki, one of the most fucked up endings in a comic ever .... really.
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
04:30 / 02.01.04
I liked the ending to the 70's Warlock comic, where the more idealized version of the character comes forward in time to kill the older, more cynical version of the character. It's been undone by Starlin (even though he never explained how Thanos came back to life), but still stands as one of the better mainstream comics endings.

I also liked the Steve Englehart Dr. Strange story where he fought a sorcerer who was traveling back in time, saoking up all the magick energy in the Marvel universe, only to get to the beginning of time and cause the Big Bang. So, in effect, he became God...and that story was never undone by Englehart, who said he saw it as how the Marvel Universe was created, making it a closed moebius strip of a Universe.
 
 
Krug
23:33 / 22.01.05
Bump.
 
 
The Natural Way
00:01 / 23.01.05
What's all this Grant's "hyper intellectual" balls? Morrison's one of the most sentimental writer's in the game. The goodies always win, spectacularly, and there's always a massive gush moment: the super-heroes at the end of Flex; Danny the World; Emma and Scott; "Is ALL NOW LOVE".... Gorgeous, warm, almost naively sweet.

There is definitely arse-talking going on up thread.
 
 
Billuccho!
00:09 / 23.01.05
I echo a lot of the sentiments made in this thread already, but I'll add Batman Year One to the list, if only for the last couple panels. "As for me-- well, there's a real panic on. Somebody's threatened to poison the Gotham reservoir. Calls himself the Joker. I've got a friend coming who might be able to help. Should be here any minute."

And yeah, Watchmen. You fellas have also listed a bunch of comics I haven't read but would love to... So I'll have to get to those one day.
 
 
Aertho
00:49 / 23.01.05
Oh Pappuce.

Grant's a smart boy, we all know, and can't-stop-saying-so. But your candor brings up a point that I was batting in my head. Grant's endings are always highly compassionate, in an obvious 'bout face to the colossal analysis of the immediately preceding revelation. Buddy sees he's a comic character, helpless at the whim of a writer, and gets his family back. Jean defeats the Lucifer Principle, mutates space-time, and then gives Scott and Emma a healthy smooch.
 
 
Aertho
00:50 / 23.01.05
Yeah, so AM26 and NXM 154 are my faves.

I'd love to add Promethea to the list... but I just CAN'T.
 
 
Krug
00:51 / 23.01.05
You're forgetting St. Swithin's Day where he dies and goes to heaven.

On a train.

It swells my heart that one.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
03:12 / 23.01.05
I absoultely cry every time I read G-Dogg's last issue of Doom Patrol. Just devestating and beautiful.

As far as super shenanigans go, who among you did not cheer at the end of DC 1,000,000? Resurrection Man dies in the quite ample arms of J'onn J'onzz and then, oh, turn the page, look at that, my God, Val Semekis, you have waited your entire life to draw a page this rad.

I quite enjoyed the last issue of Preacher. When I grow up, I want to put a two page letter in one of my comics. No, really.

And, of course, the last page of Invisibles (and The Filth for that matter) is genius, pure and simple.

Big ups to the twin barrels of the endings to both Sin City and That Yellow Bastard.

I have to say the end to Dark Knight Returns fueled a good year and a half of daydreams in the back of my head.

The end of the last Bendis/Maleev Daredevil hardcover, with Matt punishing ol' Kingpin, throwing through a window and basically telling Hell's Kitchen "DAREDEVIL, WHAT."

The end of Church & State. In a fight with the end of Jaka's Story (Oh, man, that page with Cerebus and he's dropped the paint he went out to get and thus avoided capture by the Cirinists??????? WHOA!!)

And, man oh man, Miller's Daredevil: The Man Without Fear has the best, most obvious, yet no one ever thought to think of it, gag in comics history. I can't even bear to spoil it. It rules.
 
 
Benny the Ball
04:00 / 23.01.05
SPoil it. My comics are in storage and I can't remember it. All I can remember is him jumping and his costume changing (was it the blind man costume made by reference?)

I love V for Vendetta - the stroll down the M1 was such a fantastic image.

JLA Breakdowns dragged on, but the last issue pulled it together, with the team effectively realising how bad they were and calling it quits.

I still kind of like the last page of Crisis on Ifinite Earths, the Psycho Pirate ranting about all that has happened while the continuity of everything is tidy around him.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
06:04 / 23.01.05
SPoil it. My comics are in storage and I can't remember it. All I can remember is him jumping and his costume changing (was it the blind man costume made by reference?)

Aw, hell.

Yeah, it's that gorgeous two pager of DD in the yellow costume, with the last line being "I wonder what it looks like."

Ta da!
 
 
Triplets
10:21 / 23.01.05
Earth X: Recap-Superheroes are antibodies that are unknowingly defeating anything on Earth in order to protect the unborn Celestial embryo growing within the Earth. Vibranium. Everything is Vibranium.
Franklin Richards returns to Earth outfitted in Galatacus' sink suit to fight the Celestials, after a Howard Hughes Tony Stark tries and fails to defeat them in his final Iron Man suit made up of part of a city.


I get out of work in 47 minutes and Grodd help anyone who gets between me and Forbidden Planet!

I am Galaclets! Devourer of Words!
 
 
Triplets
10:27 / 23.01.05
Oh, and the wink at the end of DC1000000.

Thanks to Randy Dupre for making me realise I'd missed the best part of the ending.
 
 
miss wonderstarr
14:05 / 23.01.05
I'm surprised if there is any consensus that Rorschach's Journal is going to be published after the end of WATCHMEN... I don't think the final panel makes that obvious.

And if it was published, would it really blow apart Ozzy's project? It's an over-written, apocalyptic, possibly-fake rant by someone who claims to be New York's most notorious vigilante; even if it's accepted as genuine, is the testimony of a stinking, right-wing street crusader going to be taken seriously? Is a column from the "crank file" of a no-budget, ultra-conservative, badly-produced newspaper going to break into the broader public sphere anyway?

Just asking because I feel this is an interesting question -- what difference would it make if the New Frontiersman did run an extract from Rorschach's Journal?
 
  

Page: (1)2

 
  
Add Your Reply