BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Comics read in December

 
 
houdini
18:52 / 08.12.03

Apologies if there's another one of these floating around somewhere and I missed it (it's not on the first three pages of the forum) or if people decided to abandon this format and I just missed the meeting....

Okay, that said, I'll kick off:

Marshall Law: Fear & Loathing
by Pat Mills & Kevin O'Neill, Titan Books
I was 11 years old when this was coming out in the original (brilliant) Epic imprint. I used to peek at it naughtily in the old Science Fiction Bookshop in Edinburgh and it always terrified and disgusted me in a delightful way. "I am the lowest form of life.

I am bacteria. I am a superhero." Basically, the setup here is Mills & O'Neill (the Nemesis team) jumping late onto the Dark Knight/Watchmen bandwagon. The story is not nearly as probing or thought-provoking as those works, but makes up for it by being so goddman nasty. The first issue starts with a superhero with a bag over his head chasing down a stripper dressed like a prominent heroine, tying a bag over her head and tossing her off a skyscraper, proclaiming, "All the superheroes should fly." If Watchmen is the De Sade of the superhero genre then this is the crime of vitriolage - a flask of acid straight to the face.
That said, I was a little surprised to find a workable (albeit obvious) mystery story tucked in here, and also that the Marshall is really an endearingly camp character once you get to know him. Plus he's embarassed 'cause his girlfriend thinks his secret identity might be gay. Awwwww....

Peanut Butter & Jeremy's Best Book Ever
by James Kochalka.
More genius from Kochalka. This one is aimed at kids, rather than his more adult stuff and it's dangerously cute. Any cuter and it would be nauseating, but I feel he keeps it on the right side of the line. Can't say much more about it. This is the kind of book that defies analysis and you prolly already know if you'll like it or not.

New X meN HC, vol 2
by Grant Morrisson, et al. Marvel.
Motivated by a 20% off sale on graphic novels at our local store, I decided to bite the bullet and grab the HC reprints of Grant's run. This is a plush, oversized volume and very slick on the inside. The work really looks great shorn of all the adds and other pamphlet trappings, and even Kordey's stuff doesn't look as godawful as I remember. Sure, there's some ugly, ugly material in there but he's also got some chops - that panel of Jean's body laying back with the wings-of-spoons halo'ing her while the Phoenix tells us, "Jean is just the house where I live"...? Beautiful.

Sidekicks, vol I: The Transfer Student
by J. Torres & Takeshi Miyazawa, Oni Press.
I heard a lot of buzz for this when Sidekicks was coming out in pamphlet form. The book is a satisfyingly small size, kinda similar to the Usagi books, only thinner. The story is... okay, I guess. There are definite flashes of something workable going on here, but at the end of 4 issues' worth of material I was left uncertain as to how much I cared about the characters or what the book was really going to be about. Nice if you like pretty manga highschool girls, but not the revisiting of classic Claremontian New Mutants territory that I'd been hoping for.

Alias, vol 2: Come Home
by Bendis, Gaydos and Mack. Marvel.
Already read vols 1 & 3 of this. This is definitely my favourite Bendis work. Jessica Jones is just a great character. She's alcoholic, she's weak, she's dumb. You can thoroughly root for her. Her sense of frustration with other superheroes and their drive for perfection is very well handled in this title. All that said, I feel there's a fairly serious gaff with the pacing in the core story in this volume. Too much builds up and then all the resolution happens off-panel in the last three pages or so. Would've benefitted from an extra issue to work things out in. One of the hazards of the decompressed style, I guess.

Alias has been cancelled and is being replaced with the rather less promising sounding The Pulse, all about J. Jonah Jameson's all-star team of super-powered Bugle reporters. I'll take a look but I expect it won't have nearly as many great scenes with drunks screwing people they're going to regret waking up next to the following day.
 
 
moriarty
19:02 / 13.12.03
I've finally got the time to start reading comics again.

Archie's Double Digest no. 8
by various

Like any anthology, you've got to take the bad with the good in this 256 page giant. In this case, we start off with the mediocre, and a story called Ear Today and Gone Tomorrow. Not much to recommend this one, with its stock poses and cluttered composition. It especially suffers in comparison, as the next story, Cover Up, is by my favourite Archie artist, Harry Lucey. It may come as a shock that I don't rank Dan Decarlo in this position, considering his reknown as the greatest of the Archie bullpen, but not only do I prefer Lucey, but I also favour Bob Montana and Samm Scwartz over Decarlo.

Anyway, Cover Up concerns Betty and Veronica's plot to turn Archie off from fishing so that he can lavish more attention on them. Never big on subtlety, their plan involves getting Veronica naked. The posing is fantastic, Lucey's hand gestures especially. He uses alot of great negative space and sense of depth, and, like Noel Sickles, he isn't afraid to make the figures really small because they already read so well. Also, that big, thick line he uses to give the cast a slick, chunky look makes him my favourite of the bunch.

This is followed up by a decent Gag Bag starring Jughead, by Bob Montana, I think. Then yet another Harry Lucey outing, called Captain Kidder. The story, about the search for buried treasure, doesn't have the panache of his previous entry, but he more than makes up for it with his art.

Heat Rave, about the kids horsing around with a hose and accidentally fooling Mr. Lodge into believing it's raining outside, falls somewhere between the first and second stories, not embarrassing itself, but not raising the bar, either. The second Gag Bag is one of the best I've ever read, with a four-panel battle of wits between Jughead, a lifeguard and a balloon. Two more gags after that which are nothing to write home about, though I liked Veronica's hair. Very Lois Lane.

Going Steady is the first Decarlo piece. It's always nice to see a story that takes two characters that don't normally interact that often by themselves and see what kind of conflict starts up. In this case, it's the unlikely duo of Veronica and Jughead. Mr. Lodge has decided that in order to improve her grades, his daughter can only date one, non-disruptive boy. Enter Jughead, who agrees to be Veronica's boyfriend on condition of full access to the Lodge pantry. It's gluttony vs. misogyny, and a sharp outfit worn by Veronica, in five concise pages.

One of the worst of many horrible features in the Archie series is the inclusion of lame illustrated puns based on themes, usually sports. Bowling Tips for Girl Bowlers is embarassing.

The Gag Bags are better than usual in this digest. Too bad my enjoyment has to be ruined by a Lil' Jinx story, Sell Me, Pretty Maiden. What a travesty. I've tried dozens of times to make it through even one of these lame ass filler pieces. Where Archie stories tend to run at breakneck speed, Lil' Jinx makes time stand still.

Old Tricks continues the time-honoured Archie/Reggie rivalry, but like the title says, it doesn't really add anything new. What this story needs is for the two characters to tie pizza boxes to their heads. By mentioning that Reggie laid a trap for Archie that would have permanently crippled him, I hope I don't give the impression that this is better than it is.

The next Gag Bag is another winner, ending on a deeply philosophical crossroad in Jughead's life. Smack! Smack! is another Decarlo selection, and at this rate, I may have to place him higher on my list. All the action takes place on one piece of sidewalk, yet Decarlo manages on making it packed with action, with the second most forceful kiss I've ever seen in an Archie comic, as well as three of Archie's best friends giving him a shitkicking. Classic intro, and a wonderful mod dress on Veronica.

I think you've all suffered enough for now.
 
 
Catjerome
01:16 / 14.12.03
I went to a comic convention recently and came home with a few fun oldskewl finds:

Hitman - I skimmed this back when it first came out and didn't care much. I'm still not madly impressed, truthfully (it's a bit repetitive with the shooting and fighting), but I did giggle a whole bunch over the banter between Tommy and his friends. Especially the guest appearance by Green Lantern - hah! "Hey, it's [logo]GREEN LANTERN[/logo]"

Muktuk Wolfsbreath, Hard-Boiled Shaman - A fun read with some interesting magical actions. To me it seemed like the quintessential Vertigo Magical Miniseries, right up there with Trenchcoat Brigade - nice concept but a little light overall, especially on character development.

Starman - Grand Guignol (most of it) - Okay, it might be my own fault for not being able to find all the issues in this story arc and not reading all of the issues leading up to it. That being said, I really did not enjoy reading this story. It was the big finale, true, but couldn't there have been more focus on Jack himself? So many guest stars and other people's stories (all those villains and Culp. What the hell? So much time spent on side characters!). Including Elongated Man, who for some reason I really fuckin' can't stand.

Plus every now and then Robinson slipped into his mega-epic style of captions - you know, along the lines of "One man ... one man stands alone against the stars ... he knows that none such as he shall fight this fight ...." I was never a fan of that style - it always came off as a bit pompous and full-of-itself to me. But then I never really liked the epic parts of Starman - I preferred it when Jack was an inexperienced ordinary guy dealing with what life throws at him and running his junk shop. When the story got all outer space and Golden Age, I lost interest.
 
 
Krug
04:45 / 14.12.03
Hey I read Sidekicks a couple of months ago. A few pages I think, couldn't get past those.

But you're on the money with Alias, Houdini. It's definitely the most charming Bendis book, can't really pick between Daredevil, Powers and Alias. Powers I'm reading in trades and still need to pick up the new one.

The novelty of Alias definitely lifts the book up from it's mire when Bendis fucks up with conclusions. I don't see too many books about a female central character who is as riveting as Jessica. There really should be more comics that aren't about Peter fucking Parker or the sodding Avengers. I'm not happy to hear it's over and Pulse sounds fairly unpromising. But Bendis seems to like the idea and I'll be there in February.

Strangehaven Arcadia/Brotherhood: This is my favourite comic right now. I'm not sure if it's the englishness, the mystery, Millidge's very responsible handling of the supporting cast, or striking art that I like best but I'm very pleased with these purchases. I hate it but I'll have to look for the next three singles because the time Millidge seems to be taking with putting out a issue would mean book 3 won't be out before 2006.

The Fall: Since Berlin book 2 won't be coming out until 2010 I might as well have this. It's been out of print sadly and it took me a while to get it. But it's worth it. Ed Brubaker is a very competent crime writer and I did forget that Lutes hadn't written the book. Which might not be the best compliment for Brubaker but it was very nicely done, one of the few books where the writing doesn't overshadow the art. Excellent symbiosis.

Amy Racer Special #1, Stray Bullets 11/12, Matrix There are no Flowers in the real world: Amy Racecar Special was a hoot. Stray Bullets 11 didn't work as well for me as Lapham thought it would but 12 was exciting. The Matrix story is probably my favourite comic right now. I'm a sucker for good story titles and the story promised what it delivered.

Murder me Dead: The backcover blurb was intrusive and had me intensely anticipating the doublecrosses. The introduction was perfect. "This is noir. Nobody changes their colours. Nobody gets off the hook. No exceptions." Incidentally I should mention that I loved hte afterword to Goldfish. To think I used to loathe noir before I read Lapham and Bendis' stuff. I still can't bring myself to watch the films but I'm loving crime fiction, which never interested me before.

Mail Order Bride: An intimate book that drew me closer with a handful of realistic scenes but left me cold in a few places because of storytelling choices. All in all, not a bad experience but I've been reading a lot of top quality stuff.

100 Bullets Vol 2,3: I read a friend's copies of 1-41 a few months ago and it was all done in two sittings. I lost interest at around 35 I think and felt burnt out by the overdose. I knew I had to come back at some point and bought the first three trades. I liked a few stories better the second time around "Hang up on the Hang Low", "Kung Pow Parlez Vous" (which I didn't like the first time around at all). In my memory my favourite story is still the two parter in 4 and 5. Will see if it was when Vol 1 arrives.

Eightball #22: Very complex and intricate. I need a second reading for a conclusive opinion but it didn't have me from page 1 like the rest of Clowes I've read. David Boring, Like a Velvet Glove, Ghost World, 20th Century Eightball. David Boring remains my favourite.

Johnny the Homicidal Maniac director's cut and Squee: While I liked Invader Zim when I checked it out I thought it didn't live up to the hype. I was avoiding these because I was certain it would be a waste of money. Someone loaned 'em to me, and I split my sides with Squee. JHTM was good but Squee was so much funnier.

Been reading a lot of comics and haven't been talking about them a while.
 
 
Krug
02:08 / 29.12.03
Transmetropolitan 58-60: Finally got these in the mail and I was hoping Ellis would know how to write a decent ending to the ten trade paperback wank. But it was shit. It was shit and I'm beginning to hate how every character was talking like Spider and how badly Ellis' meanguy dialog reads. Unsubtle powerless storytelling. Spider has been on autopilot since the Smiler got elected and the nosedive has ended with a crash. The experience has left a bad taste in my mouth.
I'll be reading Planetary but I'll think more than twice before I buy something else by Ellis.

Powers Supergroup/Anarchy TPBs: I'm not reading any other serials in trade format but Powers seem to have a very distinctive television serial quality. I have to think about this before I start talking out of my arse. But I'm enjoying it. Going to hunt the rest of hte singles so I can start fresh with Vol 2 because I can't wait another six months for the next trade.
 
  
Add Your Reply