BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Manga Recommendations?

 
 
Simplist
17:41 / 25.10.03
Assuming there are at least a few manga afficianados on Barbelith, what manga titles qualify as essential reads? Aside from the obvious three or four we've all heard about, what are the classics of the genre? What are the best ongoing titles, and why?
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
19:01 / 25.10.03
Lone Wolf and Cub: See discussion here for reasons.

Crying Freeman: By the writer (or is it artist? I'm not sure anymore) of Love Wolf and Cub, and VERY complex crime novel that shows that not all manga is aimed at Anime fans. Robert Ludlam done right.

Eagle: A masterful depiction of the first Japanese American running for US President, with unneeded soap opera elements added, but6 a brilliant look at the US political process by an outsider.

Adolph: A look at WWII that can't really be encapsulated well, but gave me a new way of looking at that war.
 
 
bencher
19:11 / 25.10.03

(not all titles will be available in english)

Three titles by Inoue Takehiko:

SLAM DUNK is now serialized in Raijin comics I think, and has a good 32 volume run that's funny, engaging, and watching the artwork develop along the way is sheer joy. The final volume of workless picture-sequence storytelling remains one of the best manga I have ever read. Note: acceptance of 6-foot Japanese powerhouses is a prerequisite.

VAGABOND is the new ongoing manga right now, that chronicles the life of Miyamoto Musashi, Japan's most celebrated samurai(I think)who will be remembered as the one who invented the technique of fighting with two swords. On a completely different wavelength from Salm Dunk, Vagabond has a more sombre take to it, though spots strong characterization and light-hearted moments all the same. Strongly recommended.

REAL is another ongoing, albeit slow manga that's about three Japanese teenageers and how their life comes together through(wheelchair) wheelchair basketball. Volume three has only been released in Japan a week ago, so much of the story remains undeveloped. From what I've read it sports a funny Slam Dunk, pardon the pun, Real-life tone to it.

find more at www.itplanning.co.jp

BLADE OF THE IMMORTAL’s probably been beaten to death on some thread somewhere, but still strongly recommended. Central at the story is the need for revenge and the morality attached to it(in feudal Japan, mind you), and while it lacks Vagabond’s storng characterization, it makes up for it with blood-bathing action. In heaps.

Now this has probably been mentioned, but the Batman two-volume story by Japanese Silent Mobius artist Kia Asamiya(BATMAN: CHILD OF DREAMS), while interesting in the visual sense, didn’t leave as strong an impression. But you might be interested in you’re a Batman fan.

Sanctuary and Crying Freeman I’ve actually not read, but intend to in the near future, anyone who’s seen it probably can tell you that the art’s pretty amazing, though I’m none to sure about the storyline.

CITY HUNTER by Hojo Tsukasa I grew up with, and it was pure fun during those (pubertal) years. The storyline gets very strong towards the end, and while a lot of the fashion trends in the comic may seem a bit early 90’s, it’s still very funny. Sequel to CITY HUNTER is ANGEL HEART, which introduces new cast members and a few of the old. I’ve been following this for a while, but dropped it recently for no particular reason other than the fact that I think I’ve probably outgrown that genre.

Other titles by Hojo Tsukasa is the short mini called RASH!!, and the 16 volume FAMILY COMPO about a teenager who moves in with his aunt, into a family that’s not really what it seems. In the series, issues of gender and family and heart are explored. Really funny stuff there.

Some of the best Hojo Tsukasa stories that I’ve read, however, have been his short story compilations(AMERICAN DREAN, MELODY OF JENNY, http://www.ex.org/5.2/33-manga_hojo.html , etc) and minis(best mini is the one about the girl connected to flowers and plants that everybody should learn Japanese or Mandarin to read, if it’s not available in English – I read it in Madarin, so have no idea what it’s called in English. If you go to http://www.hojo-tsukasa.com/portfolio/portfolio.html, it’s the one done in 93’).

DETECTIVE CONAN I actually like quite a bit, and read it whenever I get the chance. It’s a detective story by Gosho Aoyama, about an amazing teenage detective that gets shrunk down to a 9 year old’s body. A large chunk of the stody he’s trying to figure our who’s behind the whole thing, while solving other crimes along the way.

CAT, that stands for Confidential Assasination Troop, is a comic by a Taiwanese artist, Fung Jian Peng, that I picked up about a week ago. I guess that it doesn’t really qualify as manga in the purest sense, but with artwork that looks like Blade of the Immortal and a futuristic storyline with enhanced human killing machines, illustrated in pseudo Battle Angel Alita sequence, it deserves a mention. I’ve only seen volume 1 though, so.

Can’t find anything on it on the web, except for this fan page http://acidic_kink.pitas.com/ that has a good shot of the front cover of vol 1.

Sorry that I can’t give any pointers about finding all of this stuff. I think the stuff mentioned doesn’t really reflect the usual Bubblegum Crisis and other manga that a lot of people read, I’ve never touched the stuff for one reason or another, but if you’ve never read of them – it should be worth your time. There are a couple of others that I just don’t know the proper names to, so
 
 
bencher
19:20 / 25.10.03
Forgot about BATTLE ANGEL ALITA by Yukito Kishiro. LAST ORDER, the sequel to the first run(that I have, *blush* yet to finish) is already up to vol 4, as you have probably heard.
 
 
sleazenation
20:08 / 25.10.03
On a similar tack - does anyone know of any businessman manga that has been translated into Engish?
 
 
CameronStewart
22:53 / 25.10.03
I really enjoy Kenichi Sonoda's GUNSMITH CATS. If you can get past the occasional completely gratuitous T and A there's some amazingly inventive action sequences - it's the only comic I've ever read that is able to make car chases and gunfights every bit as thrilling as a film.

I also recommend Osamu Tezuka's ASTRO BOY for delightful cartooning years ahead of its time.
 
 
AlanDavidDoane
23:31 / 25.10.03
Battle Royale is addictive stuff. My review of the first volume is here:

http://www.comicbookgalaxy.com/reviews_archive_060403.html

ADD
 
 
Keith, like a scientist
00:50 / 26.10.03
aside from the ultimate manga, Akira, my absolute favorite manga read is The Five Star Stories by Mamoru Nagano. Hard to describe, but it's basically a space opera with giant robots, dragons, knights, androids, gods, demons, legends, myths....and an androgynous hero that is variously the most powerful person in the galaxy and at other times a bumbling idiot.

http://www.toyspress.co.jp/FSSe/
 
 
Krug
01:28 / 26.10.03
Dare I say Akira?

I'm hardly a fan of manga but Akira is really almost as good as everyone says it is. Almost. I think it's not really worth 150$ (I borrowed it from the library) but if you can get it supercheap or free it's a must read. I didn't begin to appreciate/like it until book 3. Otomo is an artgod.

I bought Adolf Vol 1 and it really didn't do a thing for me. I heard someone comparing it to Berlin: City of Stones which was a rubbish comparison.

I've been interested in Eagle and Ghost in the Shell for a long time but haven't really found the money for them.
 
 
sleazenation
07:36 / 26.10.03
Hmmm now i've always preferred DOMU to AKIRA, They share similar themes but have vastly different settings, and domu is shorter and consequently feels alot tighter than the sprawing confused beast that literally is Akira.
 
 
rhedking
12:48 / 26.10.03
appleseed amd ghost in the shell. Masumune Shirow is the best...
 
 
pachinko droog
16:06 / 26.10.03
WHAT???!!!! No Neon Genesis Evangelion? Oh the shame of it all...

I second Shirow. (Gotta get his calendar for the new year damnit.) And Lone Wolf & Cub is just too cool for words. If there is a comic adaptation/film remake that needs to be made, this is the one.
 
 
raelianautopsy
20:10 / 26.10.03
For classic epicness one cant go wrong with Tezuka's Phoenix. The first two trades are out now. Tezuka, except for maybe his very early work, is the best.

Some of the new Shonen Jump stories are fun entertainment; I am partial to One Piece.

Shirow is usually incredible, but the new Ghost in the Shell II is totally unintelligable. I've read all that's come out so far twice and have no idea what's going on. It's a shame, the first Ghost in the Shell was very good (much better than the movie.)
 
 
The Timaximus, The!
20:10 / 26.10.03
I've read very little manga, but Miyazaki's Nausicaa of the Valley of Wind is excellent.
 
 
mondo a-go-go
20:32 / 26.10.03
Taiyo Matsumoto's Black and White. Three books, great art.

Rumiko Takahashi's Inyu-Yasha. Basically Buffy with demons instead of vampires and sooo addictive.
 
 
LDones
22:15 / 26.10.03
I'll second Battle Royale, and then some.

I picked it up as a guilty peasure, but by the end of Volume 2 I was utterly hooked - Aside from the art being astoundingly good for a manga book, it's also surprisingly rich in emotion. Very involving, a major recommendation.

It was the first book to sell me on the Manga idea - I think I get it now.

Volume 3 should be out this week
 
 
The Strobe
08:02 / 27.10.03
As a fan of the Neon Genesis Evangelion tv series, I'd say that the manga based on it is pretty lousy. Not brilliant artwork, in fact, incredibly confusing artwork that only just makes sense if you've seen the episodes it's based on, and not well paced. One to avoid.

Huge bigups for Shirow from over here, and Domu as well - it's just wonderful.
 
 
.
11:21 / 27.10.03
I love manga, and am well pleased that a load of 'lith manga fans have appeared for this thread, but I fear that it's not particularly useful to just run off a list of titles here. After all, there is such a world of difference between something like Akira and Oh My Goddess!. There is arguably more of a spectrum of genres in manga than western comics, and unfortunately when we say manga, most people think flying robots + sci-fi + cutesy big-eyed girls.

Anyway, rant over, back to sci-fi and I'll second anything by Shirow, especially Ghost in the Shell 2 which is currently running, and is simply one of the most incredible comics ever, even if it is largely incomprehensible.

Also well worth looking out for are back issues of Pulp, now defunct, but ran some of the better leftfield adult manga, like the stylish Black and White (briefly), the compellingly revolting Uzumaki, and my personal favourite Dance Till Tomorrow, a surreal sex comedy/ romance epic. If you find any Pulps, pick one up and you can dip into a number of different stories with different styles and see what you're into before you splash out on the books.

An additional guilty pleasure is Animerica Extra, loads of candy-floss sweet soppy girls manga from popular anime, and fantastically confusingly runs both left-to-right and right-to-left (unflipped) stories...
 
 
Simplist
00:55 / 28.10.03
Thanks all, very informative. I'll be ordering the first volumes of several of these over the coming weeks.
 
 
Simplist
20:17 / 05.12.03
Just came across an excellent manga resource and thought I'd post it here for the benefit of other manga newbies: MangaManiacs.org
Excellent collection of synopses and reviews of a fairly wide variety of manga titles. The reviews tend to contain considerably more useful information than the vast majority of other manga review sites I've visited.
 
 
Baz Auckland
03:35 / 26.03.04
I've started reading some manga recently, albeit mostly things downloaded randomly from the internet... but I'll definitely have to check out some of the reccomendations above:

Hikaru No Go: I'm up to Chapter 140 or so of I don't know how many, and I've loving it. It follows a kid as he has the spirit of an old 'Go' master teach him the game. Most of the comic is just people playing 'Go', but it's incredibly fun... I really want to play Go now...

I've also read most of Chobits.. entertaining, but sort of creepy in a way, as the main plot revolves around the personal computers of the future that just happen to look like 6ft-tall cute girls that people fall in love with...
 
 
Tim Tempest
03:09 / 20.09.06
I wanted to resurrect this thread, as there seem to be quite a few interesting manga creations out there, and, being an american-comics-exclusive fan for most of my life, I know next to nothing about manga.

But the one that I'm eyeing is called The Death Note.

Has anyone here read it? I'd like to hear opinions, as to help me decide whether or not to take the plunge.
 
 
Tim Tempest
03:59 / 22.09.06
No one? No one has read The Death Note?
 
 
Panic
04:32 / 22.09.06
I'm 4 volumes into DEATH NOTE and am in absolute awe of the Machiavellian scheming and plotting between the 2 main adversaries. And now, a 3rd unknown character is making its presence felt - dramatically and violently.

Briefly, DEATH NOTE is the story of a bored Death God who leaves his notebook to be found by a human. Just for entertainment's sake, mind you. A Japanese high schooler discovers it, and its power over death, and sets out to make the world a Better Place. Regardless of how many people he has to kill. Add to that, said teen is an utterly amoral genius whose father is a high-ranking Police officer assigned to the case when criminals begin dying in droves. Throw in the aforementioned chuckling Death God (invisible to all but those who have touched the notebook), a shadowy reclusive genius detective, and an insanely elaborate cat-and-mouse game and for US$7.99 you've got one hell of a deal.

There are 3 more volumes out in the US now (I plan on picking them up soon) and according to those who've read it in the original Japanese (or fan-scan-trans, whateverthey'recalled, online) the whole status quo of the series is upended in the volumes after that.
 
 
THX-1138
13:38 / 22.09.06
I too have been reading Death Note.
I also really enjoy Hikaru No Go.
what else? ah because of Benjamin..Yotsuba&! get this now.
also Blade of the Immortal (but I wait for the tpb's).
 
 
Tim Tempest
03:24 / 23.09.06
Well, I went and picked up Death Note Volume 1. It looks pretty badass.

This is actually the very first manga I've ever purchased.
 
  
Add Your Reply