BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Alan Moore Tribute Books

 
 
Krug
11:20 / 06.10.03
I read "Portrait of an Extraordinary Gentlemna" last week and it was with the exception of a few pages in there, just a glass of fanboy cum. The bio was good, one short story about Moore's clothes was splendid but we didn't need fifty pinups and fifty "i love you alan! you changed my life!" text pieces.

"Extraordinary Works of Alan Moore" on the other hand, is simply fantastic and a joyous book that made my heart sing, dance and laugh.
Well...it was fun.
My only complaint is what I dreaded dreading all along, what some Barbelither ingeniously referred to as the "Vertigo was a tuesday afternoon wank" comments.
But that's easy to ignore and short.

The teen photos are priceless.

The book is definitely overpriced but I've only read the interview and a few of the tributes which are quite worthless. Still 25$ for a book that's largely brilliant for an extensive and revealing interview is a tough call unless you're a huge Moore fan, in which case you should've bought this already.

As unlikely as it sounds, I want a better one for Grant when he turns fifty, which isn't really that far away. Not a tribute book but something very much like "Extraordinary Works of..."

Kimota! seemed to be overpriced but I ordered it before finishing this.

So anyone else read this?
 
 
FinderWolf
17:05 / 06.10.03
I was a sucker and bought both of these; they were fun, but pricey and part of money wondered if I should have spent the money on 'em. But I agree that "Extraordinary Works of" was the better book. Kinda silly that they both have "Extraordinary" in the title. I did dig the pinups, though, being the kind who likes that sorta stuff. I am a huge Moore fan, though, so in the end I don't hate myself for buying 'em both.

I didn't buy KIMOTA!, however, just read most of it in the store. It didn't have enough to entice me to buy it.

The essay (I forget which books it's in - "Portrait", I think) by one of his daughters, talking about life with dad, is pretty funny though. On her first day of school, The Great Hairy One tells her not to answer her teacher politely and say "Yes, Ma'am" but instead to say "Jam-it, bitch!" Is that like "Suck it" in Britspeak? And the Moore daughters like to make fun of dad's mystical stuff, putting a silly hat on the authentic skull of an ancient monk Moore keeps in his living room, singing made-up songs that parody his magickal interests (i.e. "Scrying oo-ver yoouuuu...") and such. Cute stuff.
 
 
yawn - thing's buddy
19:09 / 06.10.03
read em both and the interview in the ex.works of, despite being fairly comprehensive was......pretty shite - quite tedious really.

The whole exercise reminded me of a sanitised, official biography of alex ferguson or someone.

really disappointed with both these, but then I knew I'd buy them despite vomiting at the idea of them when I first heard of the dumb books.

I'm waiting for the GM tribute to Alan Moore book, which surely must be on the horizon: I mean, he's not in either of these books so he must be doing one himself.

Yeah?

Some might say, he's done it already of course, back in DP with the beard hunter.
 
 
houdini
18:59 / 07.10.03

I got the 'Portrait...' book and, yeah, it's pretty milky. That didn't come as too much of a surprise.

One or two of the portraits of Moore were okay, but I don't really go for that kind of thing. It was nice to see pics of the BoJeffries and the Fury though, as well as some of the older characters. I could've done with DR and Quinch too.

For me the real highlights of that book were Gary Spencer-Millidge's little comic bio at the start (and I generally think GSM rocks, as well as being a v. nice bloke) and the sad, sad piece by Steve Bisette talking about working on Swamp Thing and the way his friendship with Moore fell apart. For my part, I would've been much more interested to see some similar pieces from collaborators like Davis or Seinkewicz - get some real insight into what happened with 'Big Numbers' f'rex - than any of the "We love you Alan" pieces.

Oh hell, it was for charity after all....
 
 
rizla mission
19:10 / 07.10.03
Teen pictures of Alan Moore??

Worth the entry price alone I would have thought.

Although they'd probably ruin my belief that he was born complete with the beard and hypnotic stare.
 
 
electric monk
19:55 / 07.10.03
On the plus side for "Portrait..." -> "Correspondence: From Hell" is reprinted therein and I like having that all in one book (as opposed to four issues of Cerebus).

On the minus side -> the binding on mine went all to shit before I could finish reading it and I had to fix it with rubber cement.

Haven't picked up "Extraordinary..." and don't plan too. I already spend too much money following Moore around Ideaspace.
 
 
yawn - thing's buddy
21:09 / 07.10.03
houders wins. I forgot about the bissette heart-breaker.

Such an odd piece of writing.

engrossing.
 
 
Krug
23:58 / 07.10.03
Extraordinary is very good.

Portrait isn't.

And after those books, I am not interested in hearing what his daughters have to say about him.

Portrait only had the GSM bio going for it, (didn't read the Sim correspondence yet so can't give my opinion on that).
Fanboy wank galores.

ElectricM: Extraordinary has only a handful of wanks (like this bad Neil Gaiman poem) but you shouldn't let that stop you from reading that interview.

Also loved the "This is Information" short. Give it a chance I say.
 
 
yawn - thing's buddy
10:14 / 06.12.05
yeah - the entire world should read the bissette-moore swampy story.

bissette's such a fuckin cry-baby.

moore's such a fuckin cunt.
 
 
_Boboss
12:46 / 06.12.05
so what's the rind on the bissette beef then? just a general 'artisitic moving-onwards' kinda end of the affair, or something more political, to do with funnybook contracts and stuff?

re: the thread summary, does he really take a pop at delano and milligan in the millidge book? cheeky i'd say, milligan having imho established a far clearer and idiosyncratic comic-writer voice than either beard or bald. and, as for jamie 'what do you think of my poetry, teach?' delano, didn't one's missus run off with the other's? best to let these feuds stay private perhaps?

i got one of these books, not the millidge one obvs, and it was as said upthread utter wank - i found it very hard to like or trust a chap who could bear to talk about himself in such glowing terms for such a long long time.
 
 
yawn - thing's buddy
13:34 / 06.12.05
onion de verre: bissette prose is just one big melancholic wank over a lost friendship.

it's really quite moving . . . and embarrassing.

for all concerned.

but I've never read anything quite like it.

nice and long too.

recommended accompanying tonic: skunk joint.
 
 
_Boboss
14:08 / 06.12.05
without saying.
 
 
The Falcon
18:43 / 06.12.05
I don't remember any pops at either young Peter or Jamie? Don't think so.

There's some recent stuff on the Bissette thing at tcj's messageboards. It is a really singular bit of writing.
 
 
Haus of Mystery
18:50 / 06.12.05
Go away Uncle Alan. You're upsetting the children....
 
 
The Falcon
20:33 / 06.12.05
Mmmm, here we go. All in the last month or so; Bissette and Eddie Campbell weigh in at points, pretty interesting in bits.
 
 
The Falcon
20:35 / 06.12.05
'S funny, I have no recollection of this topic first time about. Was it moved from books or what?
 
  
Add Your Reply