BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Step on up... who'd be willing to moderate?

 
 
We're The Great Old Ones Now
10:37 / 24.09.03
So I'm curious. Especially those of you who are perhaps a little less well-known on the board: after all this razzle dazzle - are you prepared to offer yourselves as human sacrifices on the altar of moderation? Or is the whole thing a big pain in the rear end?

(Moderation experiences)

Would you be willing to moderate?

Those of you who are familiar faces but don't moderate - would you do it?

Those of you who have moderated and don't any more - would you return if asked?

Is the whole question a storm in a teacup?
 
 
Ganesh
10:41 / 24.09.03
I might conceivably return to it if asked, but not for a long while...
 
 
We're The Great Old Ones Now
10:54 / 24.09.03
[grin]

I think it would be a little unfair to ask you, 'Nesh.

"Thanks so much for your good work, so sorry you're leaving. By the way, now that you've got some free time, would you mind moderating again?"

Heh. No.
 
 
illmatic
11:06 / 24.09.03
I think maybe what Ganesh's reasons for leaving consist aren't so much the moderation tasks in themseves (ie bit of HTML and abstract insertions), but as he put it the "meta-commentary" which goes alongside big shitstorms like this ie. the endless minuate and tedious arguments thrown up in the Mod vs. Haus thread. I can sympathise thoroughly with not wanting to be involved with this - the thread in question (in fact, all of the Mod vs. the board threads - in fact almost any thread involving Mod - is there a pattern here?) is both boring and exsasperating to the point of tears.

So - I'd do it, if it was a quick bit of housekeeping. But I'd have no intention of getting involved with/prolonging these kind of arguements.
 
 
The Strobe
11:16 / 24.09.03
I've PMd Ganesh already, but I can make it public - I've moderated F/TV/T for, well, since this incarnation of the board iirc, and I'd be happy to take up, say, one more moderation post. Not perhaps Head Shop as I don't read it so much and moderating there is quite intensive... but one of the lighter fora, or one I do actually regularly read, I'd be happy to help out in.
 
 
Baz Auckland
11:53 / 24.09.03
I would be a mod....

...if I'm going to be reading Barbelith all day anyway, I may as well be doing something constructive at the same time, right?
 
 
Tryphena Absent
12:03 / 24.09.03
I'd quite like to moderate Policy actually, I do like reading it, I might be a bit volatile though.
 
 
Unencumbered
12:41 / 24.09.03
I'd be very happy to moderate if asked. This board has given me an immense amount of pleasure and stimulation and it's a way of giving a little back.
 
 
The Return Of Rothkoid
12:44 / 24.09.03
If anyone wants to Mod film and Conversation, then my spots may be open soon.
 
 
Gypsy Lantern
12:46 / 24.09.03
I'd probably be willing to moderate the magic forum if there were a need for additional moderators. I've posted there regularly for years, so I'd look at it as a way for me to put something back. I find this whole odd attitude of moderation as "something to aspire to" quite ridiculous and have serious trouble getting my head around how people seem to arrive at that position. As far as I'm concerned moderation is necessary housekeeping, and if you start to think of it in any other terms then problems are going to occur. I haven't offered to moderate in the past for various reasons, but I think I'd be up for doing it now if extra moderators were required.
 
 
Our Lady of The Two Towers
14:33 / 24.09.03
Come join the Magical Mod-ery Tour!

I'm now thinking about starting a moderate thread so we can try to thrash out exactly what a moderator does and doesn't do, so that people can be reassured that moderators aren't trying to squeeze the life and soul out of the party. It's 'sort of' been done in the past but in a piecemeal fashion and usually by someone with an axe to grind, hopefully if we can do it now while there's a chance of some peace we might be able to get something which we can treat as 'settled'.

However, as to when I'll have the time to start such a thing...
 
 
Quantum
14:40 / 24.09.03

I'd mod, why not? Like jury service, it's a duty to your community. Mind you, I hang out in the Magick and Headshop and they aren't in immediate need of moderating, eh.
 
 
Linus Dunce
14:59 / 24.09.03
I'd agree do it, in principle. I've hardly ever started a thread and know squat about magic or comics but a spell in the army'd do me good.
 
 
We're The Great Old Ones Now
15:06 / 24.09.03
Now there's an idea - random rotating moderation - a one month stint, perhaps? Or a specific number of moderation decisions?
 
 
cusm
16:21 / 24.09.03
Now I know Tom likes to say Mods are also responsible for stimulating conversation and such, but I like to think that job is everyone's responsibility. Mods just get to push buttons and clean up trolls and spammers.

Though we do get our names fameously up in lights, which implies what we say must be terribly important and you all must do our bidding (so off to ebay with you, there's a piece of Sara Michelle Geller's wardrobe I've had my eye on). So, its natural to assume we must have more social duties than pushing buttons. I suppose that's unavoidable, and the mods of a forum are likely to be looked to first when there's a problem of some sort. So like it or not, there's an expectation of nannyhood implied in the job. At the least, when a thread goes off topic, the responsibility to whine about it goes first to us. We don't all do that to a great extent, but its expected, so might as well be taken into account.
 
 
We're The Great Old Ones Now
19:15 / 24.09.03
Well, that's another question - first, do mods stimulate discussion, and second, should they have that additional responsibilty?

Of course, if everything was perfect, we wouldn't need mods at all...
 
 
The Falcon
03:33 / 25.09.03
I'd do it. But I don't want to ask. I'd always thought it was like a present to the people the board-owner considers (among) the best posters.

Having done it elsewhere, I found that there was an interiorised onus to be better involved in all aspects of the board, such as they are, but also a greater inclination to be snarky to posters who are messing up your forum.

I'd be preferential to do the lighter stuff only (Conversation, Spectacle,) mind. Given the choice.
 
 
Char Aina
15:45 / 25.09.03
i think we need ot get away from that ide4a of the best posters, duncan.

that may give the impresion of the moderator castle being a towering ivory one, if ya get me.
to that end, a duffer like me would be perfect.

i'm game.


ps
don't put me in magic or headshop...
 
 
Char Aina
15:46 / 25.09.03
i keep thinking of the lordless castle in the holy grail...
 
 
cusm
15:58 / 25.09.03
Delete post action: Denied
Reason: You are stinky and smell of goat cheese
 
 
Ariadne
10:25 / 26.09.03
I'd do it if you need someone - in the conversation, books or laboratory, ideally.
 
 
The Strobe
10:41 / 26.09.03
I'd quite like to do Books but it's looking awful full.
 
 
Ariadne
10:46 / 26.09.03
It is, isn't it? I just looked and saw how many mods are there.

I can't help but imagine a dusty little cupboard that's been turned into the Book moderators' common room, with everyone squeezed in elbow to elbow.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
10:52 / 26.09.03
Fucking do it. It ain't that much hassle, it ain't an elitism thing... it's just helping out. And (the way I see it, anyway) the more mods the better- the less the accusations of some kind of clique, the quicker janitorial actions take place, the better for everyone.
 
 
Kit-Cat Club
10:52 / 26.09.03
Books doesn't need moderators, it needs threads. Honestly - I have about one action per fortnight, and I'll bet the others don't have many more than that, if any. It was even fine when I was the sole moderator - never had a problem I couldn't cope with. You would be doing the forum a bigger favour by starting more threads than by moderating it...
 
 
Ariadne
10:55 / 26.09.03
Err, okay. Good point. I'll have a think about threads.
 
 
Tryphena Absent
11:35 / 26.09.03
Haha, books is slow? Try Art, Fashion and Design on for size... forget threads just post anything relevant anywhere in the entire forum!
 
 
We're The Great Old Ones Now
13:06 / 26.09.03
Kit-Cat's right. Maybe we should put out a 'Call for threads'...
 
 
Ariadne
10:34 / 27.09.03
K-CC, there you go, I've given you two threads AND a moderator action. Don't say I'm not good to you.
I'm a bit concerned that both subjects have been covered before, though, so apologies if they have. I've done a search but may just have missed them
 
  
Add Your Reply