BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The Shy Brain

 
 
grant
14:31 / 15.07.03
Reuters Medical: Brain Region More Active in Shy People.

Young adults who had been deemed "inhibited" as toddlers had a heightened response in the brain region, called the amygdala, when viewing unfamiliar faces, researchers report in the journal Science.

The study provides a possible physical explanation for some differences in temperament, according to lead author Dr. Carl E. Schwartz, of Harvard Medical School and Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston.

"These two temperament types are like two flavors of human beings," Schwartz said in an interview with Reuters Health.

"They're not the only two," he added. "There are many, like the list of flavors at Ben and Jerry's."

Schwartz and his colleagues used an imaging technique called functional MRI to take a closer look at the relationship between temperament and brain function.

The 22 adults who took part in the new research had participated in a study of temperament when they were toddlers, Schwartz explained. At that time, researchers determined whether the children were inhibited or uninhibited using a number of tests.

One of the tests involved a battery-operated robot.

"A grad student made a little R2D2 robot," Schwartz said. "The uninhibited toddlers would walk up and poke the robot in the eye and say 'duh.' The inhibited child would freeze or even run to his mother."


and

While all 22 showed activity in the amygdala when new faces appeared, people who had been labeled shy as toddlers had a greater response in the brain region.

Schwartz and his colleagues looked at the amygdala because of its established role in emotion.

"It's known to have a central role in processing of stimuli and experiences that have an emotional content," Schwartz said.


So now I wonder what happens when the amygdala is stimulated... anybody know anything about that?
 
 
No star here laces
14:59 / 15.07.03
Ganesh will prolly correct me on this, but I believe stimulating the amygdala in monkeys provokes either a fear response or an anger response depending on location - it's commonly called an emotion centre...
 
 
Jub
07:52 / 16.07.03
The tone of the article tends to suggest that these new findings make shyness a psychological problem rather than a social one. So what if there's some region in the brain that accounts for it? and how come they are so sure that the amygdala region causes the shyness and not the other way round?

It reports that shy people have a greater (fear?) response when the amygdala is stimulated, and this is caused by (for example) seeing unfamiliar faces.... so, shy people are shy about unfamiliar things?! And… what?

There’s the implication that they’ve sussed shyness as solely down to this one area of the brain, there’s no accounting for other explanations like some sort of positive feedback loop, where shy people aren’t given the conditions to be socially confident and therefore retreat into this cycle.

Schwartz said "These two temperament types are like two flavors of human beings," – that’s as maybe Doc, but it proves nothing.
 
 
telyn
20:38 / 27.07.03
Jub, you are correct in saying that this research does not prove a causal link between the amydala and shyness in adults, however it does demonstrate an incidental link in shy adults who were shy as children.

This research has received criticism from others in the field. For instance Dr Simon Killcross, from the School of Psychology at the University of Cardiff, said that the study did not prove a "causal" link between differences in amygdalal response and shyness early and later in life.

That particular article also has more info on the subjects. It is made more obvious that the only 'shy' candidates tested were recognised as 'shy' at birth, and does not account for those whose may have grown shy as they got older, through negative feedback (as you were suggesting).

What this research really shows is that the responsiveness of the amydala is different between individuals. I really wish they had been able to test the two-year olds when with brain scans in the same way as they tested the same candidates aged 21, see if the amygdala behaves differently at different ages.
 
 
matsya
01:02 / 28.07.03
of course, you KNOW that this report is just a cover to introduce an ad for ben and jerry's into the scientific literature...

m.
 
  
Add Your Reply