BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


I know this is a really stupid question, but....mineral water and carbonation

 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
14:47 / 03.06.03
Somebody has told me, talking about a mineral lake, that the water is mineral-rich and carbonated "like Perrier". I think they mean by this that the water comes out of the ground bubbly, liek carbonated Perrier water. Am I going mad here? I always assumed that carbonation is, must be, could not be other than, a process done in factories. Otherwise how could you have sparkling and still Ty Nant? Just for starters...

Am I just very tired, or should I be giving this idea houseroom?
 
 
Bill Posters
15:34 / 03.06.03
Panic not, little one, for Canada itself has got its knickers in a twist about just this, and on the other side of the pond we see a bit or Euroscepticism as to the notion of 'natural' carbonation in Perrier water. But that's not to say it's impossible to have naturally carb'd waters, just that doubt has been cast on Perrier's marketing claims. Hence, I have not yet provided an answer to your question; that, my child, is to be found here.
 
 
Jack Fear
15:35 / 03.06.03
Apparently, some water actually does come right out of the ground all bubbly. The Greeks and Romans drank it, or bathed in it, or something. Or so we would be led to believe.

(To be fair, too, all ground water is "mineral water" in the sense that it's got minerals in it: only distilled water is pure H2O.)

This website defines different types of bottled water. Natural sparkling water is defined as "naturally carbonated, but can have C02 replaced after treatment (not more than it contained originally)". This is presumably because some of the carbonation is lost on the way from the spring to the bottling plant: the rules allow the bottler to "freshen" the water, as it were.

You can pump CO2 through plain tap water and sell it as "sparkling water," but not as "natural sparkling water." This would, presumably, explain the existence of sparkling Ty Nant.

Or maybe Ty Nant comes out of the ground fizzy, and they just let some of it sit around and go flat.
 
 
Olulabelle
15:40 / 03.06.03
[threadrot]

*Dances little jig in joyful glee*

I knew that. Which means I knew something that Haus didn't!

[end threadrot]
 
 
Less searchable M0rd4nt
17:03 / 03.06.03
[threadrot]

I knew something that Haus didn't!

Me too. *faints*

[end threadrot]
 
 
Bill Posters
10:19 / 04.06.03
[th/rot]

and better even than the fact we all knew something which Haus did not, Jack Fear knows something about Greeks and Romans which Haus knew not. Yay!

[end th/rot]
 
 
Jack Fear
13:17 / 04.06.03
I know, kids... I'm scared too!
 
  
Add Your Reply