BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


'Tommy's Tale' - Alan Cumming

 
 
Our Lady of The Two Towers
07:30 / 04.05.03
Read this over the weekend. Anyone else come across it? It's the story of Tommy, obviously, approaching 30 and realising to his initial disquiet that perhaps something in his psyche wants him to stop going to Popstarz, stop being so promiscuous with either sex, go easier on the drugs and see that settling down doesn't mean growing old. Unfortunately as these things are generally the complete opposite of what he wants from life dealing with it causes some stress.

It's not book of the year, but if you read 'The Liar' and can't help but think that the title character was Stephen Fry you won't be able to avoid doing the same with Tommy and Alan. It also seems a little padded, as the story often pauses for bon mots and observations, but Alan writes it so well that it feels churlish to mind.

What is more interesting is that Tommy, and many of his mates, are unapologetic users of a number of Class A and B drugs and enjoy sex of a number of different types and people. We're not talking 'Trainspotting' here, but for someone who is in what will be one of the biggest 'kids' (as the media will portray it) films of the summer with a career that is starting to really take off this is perhaps a little risky decision (especially the New york chapters).

The ending I'm still undecided about, but I think Alan just avoids being too fairy-tale, though that is to a certain extent a theme of the book. Worth a read, and it won't take you long to do it.
 
 
Sax
14:29 / 12.05.03
Haven't read it yet but I've read the reviews, which by and large don't seem to have been too favourable. Many were along the lines of "...he's a great actor but maybe he should stick to that..."

There have also been a few criticisms of the graphic sex - how detailed is it?

It's probably a different thread subject altogether, but should we a) damn people who are entertainers in one field for trying to cross over into another area on the grounds that why should they think they are good at, say, acting, they'll be able to write? Or b) Say that, fair enough, Alan Cumming's is an intelligent, thoughtful actor, perhaps he can bring a bit of that to fiction writing as well, it might be worth a look.
 
 
Our Lady of The Two Towers
16:11 / 12.05.03
There's some discussion of rimming, and Tommy recommends sex in disabled loos so you've got enough space. Otherwise from what I can remember there's a fair bit of sex going on, but nothing much more than what you'd expect in your average novel.

As I said, not the best book ever but a pleasant enough book for a plane/train/coach ride.
 
 
Ganesh
08:47 / 12.07.04
I've been meaning to read this for ages, but didn't want it enough to spring for the hardback. Picked up the paperback yesterday, and am halfway through it.

In general? I quite like it. Yes, it's a bit light and fluffy, and some of the anecdotery feels a little old - but the main character's fairly likeable, and it's not as if the market's crammed to the gills with likeable, convincingly-bisexual protagonists. And it does seem as if Cumming knows what he's talking about; the sexual stuff has the 'ring of truth' (and, in one case, the ring of coke) for me.

I'm not yet sure to what extent I buy the central premise - that the almost-thirty drug-guzzling hero suddenly has to 'have a baby'. Perhaps it's my own utter lack of child-wantiness, but I'm having trouble seeing where that decision actually came from. As far as I can make out, it seemed to arise rather abruptly from having an on-off fuckbuddy with a cool (if annoyingly guilt-tripping) eight-year-old kid and being on a cocaine comedown.

Still, we'll see. Perhaps I'll become more convinced of Tommy's child-bearing urges before the end...
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
00:30 / 13.07.04
It's impossible not to see the protagonist as a slight, Scottish guy with short black hair...
 
 
Ganesh
15:03 / 13.07.04
Got to the end of it, and thought 'hmmm'. And 'mehh'. And other non-commital (in-my-head) noises.

I agree, it's impossible to divorce the narrator from Cummings himself - which is unfortunate, because I rather like his public persona, and the two things uppermost in my mind as I neared the end of Tommy's Tale were 'does he really take this many drugs?' and 'is he this annoying?'

I thought Tommy got increasingly unsympathetic as the story progressed, to the point where I really didn't give a shit what happened to him on his return from New York, and only really carried on reading to find out how (in irritatingly Terry Pratchett stylee) the various relationship scenarios resolved themselves - and they pretty much did resolve themselves as they'd developed themselves ie. without much input from the main character, who seemed to drift through the narrative like flaky, fence-sitting scum.

There was one bit of the New York chapter where Tommy meets an ex-soldier in a NYPD POLICE t-shirt, and comments that he'd mythologised essentially crap aspects of himself in order to suit a perceived target demographic. Thing is, I felt this was exactly what the narrator was doing with the whole 'going to New York to get (chemically and physically) fucked' thing. He half-successfully attempted to reinvent it as a bullshitty 'rite of passage' to Being A Man, but it seemed like a serendipitously self-indulgent binge to me, which Tommy neither initiated nor attempted to control in any way.

If anything, the 'I wanna have a baby' contrivance became less convincing, impressing upon me nothing so much as Tommy's childish go-with-the-flow superficiality (from 'I'm a father!' to 'yes, an abortion was the right thing' in about five minutes).

Candyfloss. Slightly more diverting than most by way of being queer candyfloss, but candyfloss nonetheless.
 
  
Add Your Reply