BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Argentina: Workers Seize the Means of Production

 
 
Jack Fear
12:34 / 29.04.03
This story flew right under my radar, but it's pretty remarkable. In the past 18 months, with the Argentine economy in free-fall, over 200 factories have been effectively taken over and run by the workers—in a sort of industrial squatting.

And it's been an economic success: many of the factories were abandoned because the operators, even after slashing worker salaries to a pittance, couldn't even pay utilities—but operating as non-profits under the management of the workers, the factories have paid their back bills and even attracted new customers, while providing a living wage for the workers. "I don't know why the owners had such a hard time," one worker says. "I don't know much about accounting, but for me it's easy: addition and subtraction."

Is it legal? Depends who you ask. Some factories have been granted the legal right to continue as cooperative enterprises, but the government and big business are worried about the trend: "Life and physical integrity have no supremacy over economic interests," writes one Argentine federal judge.

I think it's an interesting paradigm—beating capitalism at its own game by making the factories viable economic concerns. And I'm fascinated by the idea of worker organization with its power based not on the threat of collective work stoppage, but on the promise of increased operating efficiency.

Is it theft? Is it a threat to the idea of private property? Is it the beginning of a worker's paradise? Are the workers prospering unfairly from the investments in infrastructure made by the former owners? But if the former owners were so goddam smart, how come they couldn't meet their operating costs? What do y'all think?
 
 
grant
16:36 / 29.04.03
Looks like the CIA have other things to worry about besides communists nowadays....


And loopy as it sounds, that's my honest opinion.
 
 
specofdust
17:31 / 29.04.03
Wow, I'm really happy to see this is finally working. I've never been sure whether communism could work but loved the idea. Now this is starting to work it proves that communism has a chance. I hope that the government doesn't intervene to much cos this deserves a chance. Not so sure about the CIA, I think as long as the U.S. is convinced it's all powerfull it won't keep it's nose out of other peoples business.
 
 
Jack Fear
19:15 / 29.04.03
I don't know how sutainable it is, though. Note that the factories are operating as non-profits, and seem to be just about breaking even—leaving no capital over to invest in plant improvements and replacements for obsolete/broken equipment, let alone to actually build factories of their own.

When the whole operation depends upon taking over a pre-existing facility, bought and paid for with somebody else's money... well, that puts a crimp in the large-scale applicability of this model, doesn't it?

Even an operation that seems as simple as this operates in a complex economic world.
 
 
grant
21:04 / 29.04.03
But if the factory *was* closed, and now it's open... doesn't that point towards some kind of profit? I mean, out of the red and into the black (so to speak).
 
 
Baz Auckland
22:45 / 29.04.03
Some of the factories are turning profits, it's just a matter of whether the government will let them carry on with it. It will be horrible if the government keeps using the troops to crack down on protesters and those reclaiming the factories. Some parts of the country have even switched to the barter system, given the worth of the peso.

There's more articles by Naomi Klein on Argentina at the No Logo website. It's under the 'dispatches' section. The type is really small, so copy and paste it into a word processor....

I was thinking of this being like the 1930s in North America. Partly to get out of the crisis, the government had to step in and invest massive amounts of cash, since those with the money were unwilling. Same situation here, possibly? But the government's not allowed to spend any money thanks to the IMF and whatnot, and is being forced to cut more and privatise more, leading to people taking this sort of action.
 
  
Add Your Reply