BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Police raid Italian Indymedia centre and GSF centre; mass beatings ensue...

 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
15:54 / 22.07.01
Jesus fucking Christ...

quote:Tonight the carabineraie raided the IMC as many people already have probably seen on the newswire already. As we saw it the carabineraie started by pulling up about 2-300m up the road in initially around four to five vans. They got out and started to jog down the street in riot gear and batons. People saw them and started to enter both building - the main GSF building and the school.

The school had been a safe space for people to sleep and chill for a few days. In the school there were a diverse bunch of people. As the convergence center was quite close, many people came to get information on the counter conference and the solidarity marches and also to use computers. Many people who slept in the school were participants from the marches, a group of pacifists from Zaragoza had come to the school to sleep just fifteen minutes before the arrived, (as it was the only really "safe" space to sleep) and ended up with eight hospitalised and more detained by the carabineraie.

The carabineraie, having reached the school and the GSF building started to arbitrarily beat people with the batons as people scrabbled to get inside either building. The door were closed on the GSF building but they entered from, not the main door, but one which was not secured at the side - not secured as this was just not expected.

I can only tell from what happened now from the IMC as I was there working. The IMC tried to calm people down as the carabineraie came in and demanded that all of us stand spread-eagle against the wall for about 30 minutes whilst the people wandered in and out of the rooms a bit listlessly, looking for anything incriminating - as if. They then moved everyone into one area and everyone had to sit down for another twenty minutes or so.

What they found and took was some of the equipment like mini disks videos and disks and searched many peoples bags. They also took some salad knives from the kitchen and a couple of gas masks. Later after it was all over they said to the press that they saw quite a lot of black clothes inside the rooms, well excuse me.

Apparently opposite the police took all available passports and wallets and diaries from peoples bags.

The carabineraie tried to take one of the IMC people but another journalist with G8 accreditation stepped in although he was pushed back the carabineraie left the other guy alone.

They finally left when a women MP who was in the building came to our floor and had powers to make to carabineraie leave - due to the fact that we were an international group and also journo/press. The police left, but we discovered that the people on the other floors of the GSF building had had freedom to roam after only being held on the floor for a short time. Also the GSF Lawyers office was ransacked and the computers destroyed, hard drives taken and the phones smashed – so much for the law. The computers conatined all of the info relating to legal aid etc over the last few days. The carabineraie obviously had their purpose here - one mission being to search the IMC floor to find something to discredit the IMC media movement.

After they left people immediately checked their gear and recorded what was taken, and then the keypads started burning.

Then we discovered the fucking mass beatings next door where people were already sleeping and others had been eating and talking, many IMC people stayed outside to somberly record the devastation and support those in shock and disbelief at what had just occurred. Tears and shouts of "assinos" followed the police who for another half an hour or so were still blocking off exits. Many people outside had been chanting "let them free" whilst we were up against the wall and the school was being emptied with stretcher after stretcher of young men and women being carried out.

The story from across the street in the school was that when police arrived they grabbed the first people they could outside and beat them heavily – one of the first to be beaten was a uk reporter who was smashed repeatedly by a group of them – one held him by his neck while the others beat him with clubs – unconscious he was left in the street in a pool of blood (later when we were allowed out of the building the blood had been cleaned off the pavement). Their intention was clear then from the start.

Inside the building when police entered many people inside raised their hands but the police just started smashing windows. One group then ran to the third floor and managed to escape out of an upper window and down scaffolding (the building is a bit of a building site under repair) – they were lucky. The others inside were beaten everywhere but from the long stream of stretchers came out of the building they were obviously trying to injure people as seriously as possible – at least five were brought out unconscious.

Later after more arrests in the street the police and fleet of ambulances departed, leaving us access to the building. Inside the sight was sickening. There was thick dark blood all up the walls, over the floor and at the bottom of stairs. It looked like several people had been beaten while on the ground from the blood patters low down on the walls. The scene was horrible. Even the ambulance staff were obviously shocked.

The night is long and will not end to day. This is a sad day for democracy.

As to the "weapons" they found in the school, the place was as we said earlier was under repair, a small section blocked off and littered with pipes and building materials etc Like us they too had knives (and forks!) for cooking and eating.

The local media and other reports have said police where there searching for weapons or drugs. No, it is obvious why they were here. The testimonies of people in both buildings, the blood on the street and inside the school and the number seriously injured in this so called search tells the true story. No doubt many things will be said about this horrific evening here at the GSF building, but whatever happens, Indymedia will continue to report the truth.






quote:update 15:33 GMT july 22 Reports are coming in that police are beating up people dressed in black in Piazzate Kennedy. The atmosphere is full of tension again.
Information from hospital Galleria [main] source: doctor at hospital: 29 people wounded, 3 serious. 1 very serious. British consul visited him in hospital. There is a big police presence in hospitals; people in the hospitals have been reluctant to give details. 1 US 1 swiss, remainder swiss/german
San Martino hospital: transfering people directly to jails/courts. (unclear which). wounded include broken arms, nose, head injuries. (men and women, more men). The doctor gave imc this information only after pressured to by IMC reporter inside hospital.

update 14:00 Italy time: in Charles hospital only: wounded: 14 German, 1 English, 5 from Canada/US/Turkey. Being transferred directly to Jails. They are seriously wounded included broken bones and should not be moved.

update 1:20 GMT July 22: Cell phone call ins, and indy reports are keeping us updated with events from Genova. An hour ago, POLICE STORMED the building that hosted the IMC with tear gas and batons, and the building opposite that hosted other GSF groups. About ten people escaped from windows. The police held people and took IDs. According to the medics on the scene, there have been approximately 20 seriously injured people from police violence but that no one was dead. Blood which stained the streets outside the imc quickly disappeared. Numbers of people arrested have not been relased yet.

blood covers the floors
The school opposite the IMC building was where the worst police violence occured. Floors are covered in blood. Police assault lasted over 45 minutes. Several people have been carried out in black bags. The people in the street were chanting en masse "fascist" and "bastardo". The wounded were carried out on strechers continuously and taken to ambulances that arrived with the police. Police sealed off street by surprise and a helicopter remained low overhead like a military operation. A temporary hospital was set up on the 1st floor of the IMC building to treat wounded.


Fairly incoherent with rage and terror right now...
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
15:55 / 22.07.01
Just to clarify: GSF = Genoa Social Forum.

quote:The Genoa Social Forum has hosted speakers and organizers from around the world, who talked at their counter-summit of alternatives to the current destructive economic policies pursued by Western governments and took to the streets to voice their opinions to the world leaders gathering there.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
17:10 / 22.07.01
Eyewitness report at the BBC's website

quote:Across the road though it was a different story.

The school there was being used to train campaigners in non-violent direct action.

The protesters may have put up some resistance but the police response was heavy and dramatic.

The occupants say they were made to stand against walls and then beaten by four policemen.


Please, please let this get some decent coverage in the mainstream media -sounds from what Randy said in the other thread that Channel 4 might be covering it as well.
 
 
01
02:05 / 23.07.01
Hey the Indy Media site is down. What gives?
 
 
Disco is My Class War
04:11 / 23.07.01
I'm incoherent and sad and inarticulate and outraged. But if they felt so threatened that they had to use violence on people who weren't even at the 'front lines' (and I'm not condoning this, either) at least we know how much power we have.

Send 'em some love and good vibes, willya? I know I am....

no idea why the IMC site is down though.
 
 
Spatula Clarke
04:11 / 23.07.01
It isn't - at least, not at the moment. There's no doubt that there's a huge number of people trying to access it at the moment, which may be causing the problem. Be patient and try again.

[ 23-07-2001: Message edited by: E Randy Dub It ]
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
04:11 / 23.07.01
Another report, this one via NoLogo.org:

quote:Giovanni writes "I send you some other infos about what happened in Genova (Genoa).

Saturday July 21st, after midnight (so 22nd really..) police made a surprise raid into two schools that the Genova city council has given to "Genoa Social forum", Radio Gap and IMC.

They putted a lot of strenght into their action, and the blood lines into the two schools are quite impressive to be seen.



66 young people (mostly were sleeping when police entered) have been injuried and 92 putted into prison after this action.

Police said they have done this 'cause they knew there were weapons inside (it seems they found 2 molotovs, some knives and bars), and they wanted to demonstrate there were no difference between the social pacifist movement and the "black blocks" (who are supposed to have made shops burning and "civil war").

Here comes the interesting part:

- On one side police and mr. Berlusconi are tryin' to say that all the "popolo di Seattle" (Seattle people, ehm..) is to be considered responsible for city destruction in the yellow zone.

- On the other side Genoa social forum (who tried to rule the protest in Genova) is sayin' that police was deliberately doing nothing to stop city destruction and that THEY WERE HELPING "BLACK BLOCK" doing it.

There is a movie made by an italian quite important director, Davide Ferrario, in which it seems that police was giving road indications to black blocks, while was acting hard with "normal" demonstrators.

He also filmed a group of police men dressed as hard demonstrators.

U can look for more infos at: http://www.repubblica.it/online/politica/gottodiec i/chiuso/chiuso.html (in Italian, please note that "la repubblica" is an usually equilibrate newspaper)"
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
13:24 / 23.07.01
The reports keep coming:

"I think I’m calm, that I’m not in shock, but my fingers are trembling as I write this..."

And the best page yet for links to reports, video and audio footage etc:
http://sf.indymedia.org/display.php?id=102089

Including this eyewitness account from a BBC journalist who was in the building:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/olmedia/1450000/audio/_1450876_raid_hayton0200.ram

More video:
http://www.repubblica.it/video/2001/07/22/01.html

There's talk of a demo outside the Italian Embassy in London this Saturday, 2pm, if anyone's interested:
http://www.uk.indymedia.org/display.php3?article_id=7539

[ 23-07-2001: Message edited by: The Flyboy ]
 
 
Mordant Carnival
15:28 / 23.07.01
I just can't even get angry anymore. Think I've blown some kind of fuse.
 
 
Ierne
15:56 / 23.07.01
We know that they have arrested everyone they take to the hospital, taken people to jail and tortured them. One of the young Frenchmen from our training, Vincent, had his head badly beaten on Friday in the street. In jail, they took him into a room, twisted his arms behind his back and banged his head on the table. Another man was taken into a room covered with pictures of Mussolini and pornography, and alternately slapped around and then stroked with affection in a weird psychological torture. Others were forced to shout, “Viva El Duce!” ! ! Just in case it isn’t clear that this is Fascism. – Starhawk

That certainly shorted my fuse. I'm numb...although I think if I hear one more idiot at my job go on about "nasty anarchist hooligans" I may just walk out and go home.
 
 
rizla mission
17:47 / 23.07.01
I suppose it goes without saying that I consider this nothing short of completely obscene, to the degree that if this isn't widely reported, and if the Italian authorities are not soundly reprimanded by whatever international bodies do that kind of thing...

...then I'll have to leave my current fence-sitting position and get properly involved with all this stuff.

(Christ, I sound like a politician..)
 
 
Disco is My Class War
01:20 / 24.07.01
Rizla, that's just the point. There are no 'international authorities' that will reprimand the Italian state. The mainstream media coverage, at least here, has already finished with no sign of reporting how many people have been arrested, injured in the course of arrest, or the fact that the police stormed a place of peace. The 'authorities' are the very bodies that were being 'protected' by the Carbinieri.

How many times is it possible to point out that we don't live in a democracy before people will actually believe it and act on that belief? I mean, it's easy to know it in a vaguely theoretical way. But how else to bring it home that no-one is going to do anything about this but 'us', the people?
 
 
Frances Farmer
01:42 / 24.07.01
It would appear that the movement required a martyr.

Not that this serves to assauge any concerns, but Amnesty International has photographed the bloodstains and is involved in an official investigation.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
07:12 / 24.07.01
Five Britons arrested in the raid on the GSF could face up to five years in prison if jailed - names and details here:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/breakingnews/UK/0,2478,1064540,00.html

(Obviously British people getting jailed for this is no more important than any other nationality, but if UK people want an avenue to pursue you could do worse than keeping an eye on what happens to these guys...)

Just been watching some of a journalist friend who was in Genoa's footage of the march on Saturday - what hits home again is the fact you don't even see any footage of peaceful protest on the news: they may give statistics as to the number of peaceful demonstrators, but these are always juxtaposed with images of smashed-up banks, etc and the self-fulfilling statement by the media that "the violence has overshadowed the message of the protestors"...

My friend was at the Indymedia centre on Saturday - more than a little appalled and disbelieving about the raids on Sunday... apparently he and some others went back there on the Monday to find the Indymedia and GSF buildings surrounded by the paramilitary guys whose names I can't spell (carabinieri?). As soon as they got out of the car and started filming just the outside of the building they were stopped and detained etc... fairly lucky to get away with their cameras intact, I think.

Anyway: he's writing a piece which will probably focus largely on the media coverage (and distortion of events) for a sunday magazine here: it's just a shame it won't be out for a while, but the more voices we've got at least deviating from the official line on these events the better...

Addendum:
this story at the Evening Standard's website strikes me as quite telling in how it reveals the British press' take on these things. On the one hand: how dare the nasty foreign Italian police kick the shit out of one of our boys? On the other hand: it's full of the usual bullshit distortion, including this quite shocking sentence:

quote:The raid followed 48 hours of violence in the city during which one Italian was shot dead and up to 1,000 anarchists attacked police, laid waste to banks and shops...

...which cannily fails to mention that the guy shot dead was either a) a protestor, or b) shot dead by the police. (They do mention this in the last paragraph, but positioning is all in this kind of journalism...) I've seen and heard that little elipsis a few times over the past couple of days actually, and it's really revealing and just a bit scary: phrasing along the lines of "the riots, which left one man dead etc" are common.

[ 24-07-2001: Message edited by: The Flyboy ]
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
07:12 / 24.07.01
For anyone in the UK wondering "what can I do?":
http://uk.indymedia.org/display.php3?article_id=7636

quote:
Nicola and Richard were arrested while they slept, obviously they recieved injuries unwarranted during arrest of sleeping people. They have been charged with the same offences as ninety other people. There is a claim of NINETY people in the same building ALL having similar weapons

URGENT
For IMMEDIATE ACTION!

_______________________
Dear Folk,

We have bad news.

Nicola Doherty and Richard Moth have both been charged by the Italian authorities.

News is still filtering through, but this is what we know at present:

Nicola is suffering from contusions to the head and a fractured wrist, Richard from head injuries.

They have both been charged with four offences:

Criminal Association
Resistance to Public Officers
Possession of Arms
Possession of offensive weapons

Nicola and Richard were arrested while they slept, obviously they recieved injuries unwarranted during arrest of sleeping people. They have been charged with the same offences as ninety other people. This is indescriminate scapegoating. There is a claim of NINETY people in the same building ALL having similar weapons. After the behaviour of the Italian police over the weekend no one can believe these claims - not even the most hardened reactionary.

The charges mean that Nicola and Richard cannot be contacted for a further 48 hours. The British Consulate may contact them if they give the authorities 24 hours notice (it is unclear whether they have given notice at this stage).
___________________________________________________________________________

WHAT CAN YOU DO?

Firstly you can ring the Italian Embassy in London to voice your concerns for the saftey of Nicola and Richard and demand their immediate release. Their phone number is 020 7312 2200.

Below is an open letter - we need dignitaries, union reps, and every single name we can gather on this open letter and fast. We will be handing in the letter to the Italian Embassy tomorrow. Please get what support you can and e-mail it back to us ASAP. (office@resist.org.uk)

____________________________________________________________________________

RELEASE NICOLA AND RICHARD

Nicola Doherty and Richard Moth, two Globalise Resistance members, have been arrested by Italian Police after the Genoa protests at the weekend. Both work with adults with severe disabilities and are members of Unison trade union. Nicola was on her first demonstration. Neither were involved in any violence during the protests in Genoa. Both are being held incommunicado, with no accesss to legal support or contact with their friends and families. Both recieved considerable injuries while they were being arrested.

To claim that NINETY people were all guilty of the same offences while they slept is ludicrous.

We demand that their lawyers and friends be allowed access to the two prisoners immediately. We demand these two peaceful protesters are released immediately.
If any weapons were indeed found at the HQ, their is nothing to suggest Nicola and Richard were in possession of them.

Arrests and oppression will not answer the case put by anti-globalisation protesters.

John Pilger, journalist
Louise Christian, lawyer
Paul Foot, journalist
Noreena Hertz, writer
Mark Steel, journalist
Candy Udwin, University College London Hospital UNISON
Guy Taylor, Globalise Resistance
____________________________________________________________________________

We can really make a difference on this case - we stopped the train getting cancelled, we can spring these two from unwarranted incarceration.

We depend on your action and support,

Guy Taylor
Globalise Resistance


Note that this is from yesterday - so they may have already handed the letter in. However, you can still call the Italian Embassy and, please, spread this around.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
11:40 / 26.07.01
Just to keep things up to date... Some good news - four of the five British protestors arrested have been released and are back in the UK (Mark 'Sky' Covell is still in hospital but has not been charged with anything, despite the Daily Mail's mildly delusional insinuations that he was BEHIND THE WHOLE THING...). There's a full transcript of their statement on arriving at Heathrow here - I was tempted to start a new thread and quote the whole thing. Key bit:

quote:We are deeply moved by the tens of thousands of people around the world who came out on the streets to support us and have warm memories of the sympathy, hospitality and solidarity of the majority of Italian people we came into contact with.

We also condemn what we assume to be Tony Blair's refusal to criticise the police violence against ourselves and others.

We will continue to stand up for our beliefs and a picket outside the Italian embassy will be held at 3pm on Saturday.


Potentially even better news: the Italian paper La Repubblica has a statement from an anonymous policeman whose account of what went on that night is more chilling than some of the protestors'... it's in Italian here, translated slightly clumsily here but, perhaps most importantly, also mentioned by the BBC in their latest news story on Genoa here:

quote:But a police source has compared the operation to a "nightmare under Pinochet's Chilean dictatorship" and accused some of his colleagues of behaving like fascists.

He told the respected Centre-Left daily La Repubblica: "They lined them up and banged their heads against the walls. They urinated on one person.


Suddenly, it looks like there might be the chance for this one not to get covered up - the tone of the reports in the UK pree, for however spuriously patriotic reasons, are shifting:

Other BBC stories: here and
here.

Leader comment in the Indepedent today criticising Blair's support for Italian police (with a really weak conciliatory final paragraph, actually... "at least as bad"? Fucking hell...)

Mark Steel in the Independent: Blair's response was, in effect, to say: "I utterly condemn the behaviour of those people who flouted our democracy by being shot. They'll say they were exercising their democratic right to be shot, but if they can't be shot peacefully they have no right to be shot at all."

News story in the Independent

And in the blue corner...

The Times' coverage.

The front page of The Sunday Times has a link to a piece by a journalist beaten up by police.

Surprisingly sympathetic coverage from the Telegraph, including an interview with Mark Covell (originally on Radio 4, I think there's an audio file of it somewhere).

Edit - yes, there is: if you have RealPlayer, do 'open location' and then paste this in:

pnm://rm.bbc.co.uk/radio4/live/today4_20010726.ra?title="Exclusive! The first interview with the British protestor still in a Genoa hospital"&start="00:08:52.8"&end="00:16:10"

It's appalling. He describes his injuries in detail, talks about the fact that he's just a FUCKING JOURNALIST, he wasn't even on the streets... Jesus. It's chilling, and you realise why the British press have had to change their tune a bit, even if they're giving this much less coverage than they gave the protestors' 'violence' (love the way that usually police 'brutality' ends up in scare quotes but violent rioting doesn't...)

Other stuff:

More sympathetic coverage in the Evening Standard

And I've just heard that despite having said earlier in an interview with Radio 4 that the security was needed to protect the summit from a minority of violent people with "slightly mad political views", Jack Straw has now said there will be an inquiry. More as and when...

[ 26-07-2001: Message edited by: The Flyboy ]
 
 
Ierne
12:29 / 26.07.01
It's nice to see the British Press keep pushing on this topic...because it's being buried big time over here. I checked cnn.com and their top news story for italy this morning was this.

Then I did a search under "genoa" and got a few measly articles.

Think I'll try the NYTimes now...ouch...
 
 
Ierne
12:41 / 26.07.01
ONE article in nytimes.com. It's not even covered in "International", it's in the "From Reuters" section. You have to register to use the NYTimes website so as to save y'all time and effort here's the sole solitary article:

Italy Under Fire for Police Behavior at G8

By REUTERS
Filed at 9:31 a.m. ET

ROME (Reuters) - The Italian government on Thursday came under increased pressure at home and abroad to respond to allegations that demonstrators at last week's G8 summit in Genoa were brutally beaten and denied their human and legal rights.

As witness' accounts in media throughout Europe and criticism from parliamentarians and human rights groups poured in, Genoa's prosecutor's office opened a third investigation into alleged police brutality.

A judicial source told Reuters that prosecutors were looking into possible charges of assault, bodily harm and abuse of office by police on activists detained in jails.

The other inquiries focus on a police raid on a school used as sleeping quarters of umbrella protest group the Genoa Social Forum (GSF) and alleged beatings at a police station.

They are part of a whirlwind of investigations after demonstrations drew more than 200,000 protesters to Genoa.

One was shot dead and more than 231 injured in two days of violence. Police initially arrested 280, many of them foreign, though many have now been freed.

``There has been mistreatment in police stations which reminds me of the depictions of Argentina during the military dictatorship,'' senior German Greens politician Hans-Christian Stroebele told Germany's FAZ business radio after visiting German activists detained in Genoa.

The German government also has expressed concern. A Foreign Ministry spokesman said Germany would contact the Italian authorities, if necessary.

ALLEGED BEATINGS

Sharp criticism of alleged police beatings has also come from Italian opposition politicians, who filed a parliamentary motion asking for Interior Minister Claudio Scajola to resign.

An opposition demand to set up a parliamentary committee to investigate the Genoa events was rejected by the center-right ruling coalition headed by Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi.

Scajola has said the police acted with professionalism and had the government's full support. Police chief Gianni De Gennaro said individual officers would be punished if they had committed abuses.

Witness accounts of alleged police beatings were carried by several mayor European newspapers such as El Pais, Le Monde and the Berliner Zeitung.

A witness of the police raid against the GSF school told Reuters on Wednesday he would file a complaint against the police's behavior.

Michael Gieser, 35, a freelance economic adviser and business trainer from Luxembourg, said: ``When police came in, we all laid down on the floor face down with arms and legs spread without resisting.

``They took advantage of our position to hit us with batons, kick us, and hit us very hard with extreme violence.''

Some 92 people were arrested in the raid and many injured. Police, who seized several weapons, said they entered the school because they thought violent protesters were hiding there.

Police said some protesters had resisted arrest and attacked police officers. The GSF denies this.

A judicial source told Reuters all 92 had been freed, with no charges pressed against the vast majority of them.

London-based human rights group Amnesty International complained some detainees had not been allowed to contact family, lawyers or consulates until three days after the raid.
 
 
Opalfruit
13:08 / 26.07.01
Hmmm, this morning as left the house the News Reader on the CH4 Big Breakfast was reading an article on Mount Etna dying down and using something along the lines of "and finally Mount Etna has shut up without the need of the Italian Police Beating it into silence"....
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
07:10 / 27.07.01
Front page of today's Telegraph - the most right-wing broadsheet in the country...

This one might just not go away...
 
 
Ierne
13:23 / 27.07.01
CNN...finally...
 
 
Ierne
18:40 / 02.08.01
Too bad the BBC aren't being literal about the Italian police getting scalped.
 
  
Add Your Reply