BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Six Feet Under: Crisis On Infinite Nates (SPOILIDGE)

 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
09:17 / 04.03.03
Alan Ball On Season Three:

"Season three, thematically, is all about choices," he says. "The implication being that on some level, Nate chose the reality that he ends up in at the end of episode one. Now that's taking all kinds of metaphysical and theological liberties, all in the name of poetic license. When you're called upon to make a choice in your life, in your personal life, doing the right thing is not always the easiest thing to do and it doesn't always reward you as much as other choices might."

He continues, "Sometimes being a moral person and doing what is right actually makes your life more difficult. When you do make a choice, you're saying no to a lot of other choices, and that's what we try to focus on...the dilemmas that creates for our characters and the scrapes they get in because of that and how it makes their life ridiculous and absurd and messy and funny, and also better and richer an equal part of the time as well. And how it's just never simple. You know, life just continues to get more and more complex for these people."

For those of you who haven't seen it yet, I'll spoil it for you. Nate spends the first twenty minutes of the episode walking through almost a dozen possible realities, each one a seperate room of his house. It's kind of an Invisibles meets the Black Lodge kind of feel and it's an amazing, and effective, sequence. All of the show's trademark strangeness focused into a powerful statement about free will, choices, and (get this) alternate realities.

There's much belly-aching already about the first episode (Sopranos Season Four Style), as Nate has ended up in the least exciting situation for himself. Never ones to let a season actually play out before judging it all out of proportion, everyone's pretty much dismissed it outright. Some have even speculated that the whole season (or at least the first few episodes) will be revealed as yet another vision in Nate's head. I thought briefly of this, and its hinted at severely with lots of deja vu, but I don't think that's what'll happen. Thanks to errant sperm, Nate's stuck with a wife who idolized him dangerously for eight or so years when they were friends in Seattle and now she's pretty much pinned him into marriage. There's a look on his face when sees the reality in which he and Brenda ended up together with a child, a happiness, that you know will never be replicated in this real world he's ended up in. But, hey, that's, literally, life. Oh, and he also caught his mom internally monologuing out loud while feeding his baby about how Nate was an accident. There is then much musing on what the hell the point of any of this randomness that is life really has.

Anyone think they'll come up with a solid answer for us?

I picked up the first season box set trepidatiously, as it's twice the price of most TV boxes and half the size with thirteen episodes, but if any show was worth it, it's this one. Seeing just the first two episodes I was reminded, above all, that this show displays the best performances on television bar none. A world where Michael fucking Chicken (Chiklis! Whoops! Genre City spoilers!) beats Peter Krause out for an Emmy award, EVER, is an alternate reality I am desperately interested in escaping. Not to mention Lauren Ambrose, who I don't think was ever even nominated and, sadly, I think her best material may be behind her. When she was stumbling through Season One, decimated by her father's death in ways she would never admit, every episode was revelation. Now she's fucking a The-Guy-From-Audioslave wannabe. Oh, well, I'm sure it'll turn out interesting, to say the least. Maybe Gabe'll come back and totally shoot him.
 
 
Tamayyurt
20:05 / 04.03.03
I've never seen this show before and I just happened to catch it last Sunday (more randomness) I love it. It's so... me!
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
20:11 / 04.03.03
Are you trying to say that you do nothing but whine incessantly and spew psycho-babble?
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
20:52 / 04.03.03
Yes. That's exactly what he's saying.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
21:05 / 04.03.03
So, anyone want to actually discuss the show? More blanket statements are welcome, too.....
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
21:14 / 04.03.03
Well, it wasn't as bad as usual, but that's probably a lot to do with me conciously trying not to dwell on the obnoxious parts of the show that I already hate. So, all in all, it was okay in spite of the show's inherant flaws.

Lily Tomlin was pretty good. Lauren Ambrose and Peter Krause were alright. Rachel Griffiths was barely in it, and that's a major plus.

I still want to smack the shit out of the gay son. The degree to which that character is obnoxious is just off the fucking charts.
 
 
8===>Q: alyn
01:40 / 05.03.03
Flux, every character on the show is a complete asshole in his or her own special way, which I think is probably where the whole "my God, this is just like real life" sensation comes from, cuz, well, you know. It's not a show about people at their best.

I thought it was good but pretty ennervating. Everyone seems to be in hiding from any of the possibilities they might have had before them last season, except for Rico who is being an insufferable little asshole. I wonder what's going on at home for him. I think Nate is starting to resemble his father more than a little. Claire's new beau is a horrible little twerp. What she needs is a dashing 28yo journalism student from Brooklyn.

I kept expecting it all to be a dream, but I'll be surprised if they actually go that route, though the alternate reality stuff in relation to a normal person's problems and choices is interesting. I'm not sure where Ball is getting all this stuff about moral choices from. Does he mean marrying the mother of his child? Couples therapy? Zuh?
 
 
iconoplast
02:00 / 05.03.03
I love the show, so I'm not really going to pretend I can be objective about judging it.

I just wanted to point out that, while Nate is maybe dead or not, he hallucinates himself in a white trash existance watching a soap opera in which Dr. Schrodinger and a starlet trade cliches about the world splitting in two.

Then, when Nate, imagining himself at his own funeral, asks his father if he's alive, his father more or less gives a summary of schrodinger's cat, and then points to the (closed) casket.

My reaction: "If a cat jumps out, I'm not laughing."

I was really hoping Nate would wake up with Brenda, because she's just badass and I hate Lily Tomlin's insufferably smug hippy character.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
02:15 / 05.03.03
Sorry, it's an easy mistake (it's actually Lili Taylor), but I've just envisioned that black and white vampire movie, The Addiction, starring Lily Tomlin. That low Tomlin voice searching for blood. Classic.
 
 
iconoplast
02:41 / 05.03.03
Taylor, right.

Though... Lily Tomlin, I'm imagining, could also play an insufferably smug hippy.
 
 
Tamayyurt
03:31 / 10.03.03
I just noticed after tonight's episode... This current universe may very well be fake. Nate's daughter is named Maya... Hindu goddess of illusion and all that.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
09:11 / 10.03.03
*Check Vese Spoilas Befo' You Wriggity-Wreck Em.*










I think tonight's episode pointed things firmly in the real world camp. Felt like old times. The most startling death of the series (I really keep expecting them to get tired but they nearly ALWAYS end up pretty much stunning me), some great Rico developments, more insight into Nate and Lisa's relationship, a classic Ruth moment ("DO YOU WANT ME TO BREAK THIS ARM, BECAUSE I WILL!"), and, wow, Claire seems to be taking an interesting route. So, has pretty much everyone been a Russell at one time or another? It's a total cliche but I think give it enough reality and depth (what a shock) that I totally bought it. And had a sincere desire for Captain Crunch.
 
  
Add Your Reply