BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Thought Crimes

 
 
000
22:02 / 22.02.03
Has anyone else read THIS?

Reply as if your opinion counts.

Which it does.
 
 
bjacques
12:32 / 23.02.03
Guess they'd better fix that. Laws are like software--full of holes and bugs that can be exploited by ambitious prosecutors and other lawyers.

While I can understand the thinking behind "hate speech" laws (especially Continental ones), I've always found them disturbing. Unless the laws are narrowly confined to immediate incitements to violence or panic, or for libel or slander, they sit there like a trap for the unwary or like a loaded gun hidden away for those who know how to use it. For example, anti-Scientology website owners, long vulnerable to abusive copyright and libel suits, could now face criminal charges by $CN lawyers, and perhaps be extradited to the country with the harshest laws. $CN have lately been the first to exploit new laws to shut down their critics. Other U.S. corporations, using their status as legal persons, have used libel laws against their critics.

This is definitely slippery slope territory, especially now that the US and UK are revisiting the old concept of sedition. It's not that big a leap. Three cheers for the US government hostility to the EU; Ashcroft could otherwise fuck over expat critics.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
13:20 / 23.02.03
Double plus ungood, and open to a huge amount of abuse. From this you could leap (and not that far) to equating a healthy suspicion of the Catholic Church, say, to recruiting for the Klan or Holocaust denial.

Slightly insolent note- wonder if the websites of the various UK tabloids could get prosecuted for their recent anti-French stance? Which has, I must add, crossed the line from criticising their political stance to out-and-out xenophobia. (The Sun, I think it was, last week published a list of schoolyard-standard anti-French jokes. Eating funny-smelling food, having sex with farm animals, that kind of thing.)
 
  
Add Your Reply